ConnectorIO OpenHAB 3.x BACnet Add-on won't install

temcocontrols · March 26, 2023, 4:03am

Maurice from TemcoControls.com here, we’ll do our best to help out. Asher, have you tried just reading and writing directly to the bacnet instance of the subnet devices. The T3 controller should be able to pick up any IP based messages destined for subnet devices and route packets transparently to the subnet and back. There’s no programming required on board the T3 controller to set that up. For general bacnet debugging we use Yabe which I see from reading this forum a bit more just now you are well familiar with. If you can see our subnet devices with that you should be able to see them from your OpenHab environment.

Also here’s a writeup I did for using wireshark on RS485 / MSTP subnets, this could be helpful in your MSTP debugging: https://temcocontrols.com/troubleshooting-bacnet-mstp-traffic-wireshark/

We’re standing by to help out more.

awald · March 27, 2023, 9:58pm

After looking at wireshark traffic one difference I see is yabe generates “structured-object-list” requests and Wacnet generates “object-list” requests. I don’t have a BACNet spec so I don’t know the difference.

The yabe request generates an “error” response while the Wacnet request generates an “abort” response.

splatch · March 27, 2023, 10:37pm

Can you cross check that with YABE? Key aspect is how request is being addressed. We know that both wacnet and openhab binding can’t reach device behind T3. If you can confirm yabe can pass it and read out sensors connected to controller we just need to make sure we follow same addressing.

awald · March 27, 2023, 11:08pm

This is long so breaking into two parts. Here’s the packet trace from WACNet. 192288 is the T3-TB on Ethernet. 194235 is the TSTAT on an RS485 subnet.

WACNet reads and populates the objects in 19288, but not 194235

530	4.832077	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.255	BACnet-APDU	75	Unconfirmed-REQ i-Am device,192288
541	5.009839	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.255	BACnet-APDU	70	Unconfirmed-REQ i-Am device,194235
734	5.723329	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	69	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 8] device,192288 protocol-services-supported
738	5.731939	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	77	Complex-ACK readProperty[ 8] device,192288 protocol-services-supported
741	5.736033	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[230]
742	5.736116	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[231]
743	5.736150	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[232]
744	5.736189	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[233]
745	5.736227	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[234]
748	5.741531	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	73	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[230]
754	5.748066	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	64	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[238] device,194235 protocol-services-supported
757	5.750904	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	69	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[239] device,192288 protocol-services-supported
758	5.752192	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	76	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[231]
764	5.760982	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	64	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 10] device,194235 protocol-services-supported
767	5.763729	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	73	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[232]
774	5.774442	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	76	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[233]
777	5.783742	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	69	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[241] (128) Vendor Proprietary Value,5 present-value
778	5.784171	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	69	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[242] multi-state-value,1 present-value
779	5.784264	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	73	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[234]
780	5.788505	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	69	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[243] calendar,3 present-value
786	5.801075	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	77	Complex-ACK readProperty[239] device,192288 protocol-services-supported
794	5.816020	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	76	Complex-ACK readProperty[241] (128) Vendor Proprietary Value,5 present-value
795	5.818708	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	75	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[244]
796	5.824651	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	71	Complex-ACK readProperty[242] multi-state-value,1 present-value
808	5.830039	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	64	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[247] device,194235 protocol-services-supported
810	5.834685	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	71	Complex-ACK readProperty[243] calendar,3 present-value
813	5.844717	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	91	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[244]
849	6.012405	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	72	Complex-ACK readProperty[238] device,194235 protocol-services-supported
936	6.329568	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[248]
938	6.337256	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[249]
939	6.338570	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[250]
940	6.339115	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	76	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[248]
944	6.348695	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	76	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[249]
945	6.356115	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[251]
946	6.357979	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	72	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[250]
949	6.361029	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[252]
950	6.361076	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[253]
962	6.367581	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	73	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[251]
965	6.377072	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	73	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[252]
966	6.379207	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	69	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[254] calendar,1 present-value
967	6.386385	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	72	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[253]
970	6.395788	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	71	Complex-ACK readProperty[254] calendar,1 present-value
1721	11.730155	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	69	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 8] device,192288 protocol-services-supported
1726	11.738788	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	77	Complex-ACK readProperty[ 8] device,192288 protocol-services-supported
1732	11.781698	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	64	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 10] device,194235 protocol-services-supported
1734	11.782826	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	64	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[238] device,194235 protocol-services-supported
1740	11.832375	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	64	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[247] device,194235 protocol-services-supported
1760	12.028666	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	72	Complex-ACK readProperty[ 10] device,194235 protocol-services-supported
1796	12.525029	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	72	Complex-ACK readProperty[247] device,194235 protocol-services-supported
2140	17.743001	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	69	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 8] device,192288 protocol-services-supported
2144	17.753466	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	77	Complex-ACK readProperty[ 8] device,192288 protocol-services-supported
2146	17.794058	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	64	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 10] device,194235 protocol-services-supported
2148	17.795592	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	64	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[238] device,194235 protocol-services-supported
2149	17.845643	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	64	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[247] device,194235 protocol-services-supported
2157	18.034342	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	72	Complex-ACK readProperty[ 10] device,194235 protocol-services-supported
2335	20.283752	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[255]
2336	20.286996	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 0]
2337	20.292878	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	73	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[255]
2338	20.295829	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 1]
2339	20.297415	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 2]
2340	20.301845	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 3]
2341	20.302194	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 4]
2342	20.302288	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	76	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 0]
2343	20.310900	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 5]
2344	20.313695	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	73	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 1]
2345	20.323184	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	76	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 2]
2348	20.336144	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	73	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 3]
2349	20.339783	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	69	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 6] calendar,3 present-value
2350	20.346207	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	73	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 4]
2351	20.356655	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	78	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 5]
2352	20.365693	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	71	Complex-ACK readProperty[ 6] calendar,3 present-value
2373	21.355534	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 7]
2374	21.355615	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 8]
2375	21.356076	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 9]
2378	21.361341	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	76	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 7]
2379	21.370216	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	76	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 8]
2380	21.371381	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 10]
2381	21.379185	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	72	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 9]
2382	21.379842	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 11]
2383	21.380900	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 12]
2384	21.388915	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	73	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 10]
2385	21.399668	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	73	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 11]
2386	21.401796	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	69	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 13] calendar,1 present-value
2387	21.408977	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	72	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 12]
2388	21.417654	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	71	Complex-ACK readProperty[ 13] calendar,1 present-value
2801	35.300597	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 14]
2802	35.300651	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 15]
2803	35.306430	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 16]
2804	35.306476	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 17]
2805	35.307416	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	76	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 14]
2806	35.316383	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	73	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 15]
2807	35.320492	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 18]
2808	35.325322	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	76	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 16]
2809	35.326969	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 19]
2810	35.327012	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 20]
2811	35.334648	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	73	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 17]
2812	35.344166	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	73	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 18]
2813	35.346972	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	69	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 21] calendar,3 present-value
2814	35.353677	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	78	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 19]
2815	35.364137	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	73	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 20]
2816	35.372698	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	71	Complex-ACK readProperty[ 21] calendar,3 present-value
2844	36.348133	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 22]
2845	36.348182	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 23]
2846	36.348579	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 24]
2847	36.358517	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	76	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 22]
2848	36.366993	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	76	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 23]
2849	36.376507	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	72	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 24]
2850	36.376875	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 25]
2851	36.377111	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 26]
2852	36.378277	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 27]
2853	36.385823	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	73	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 25]
2855	36.395619	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	73	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 26]
2856	36.397916	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	69	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 28] calendar,1 present-value
2857	36.404708	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	72	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 27]
2858	36.414291	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	71	Complex-ACK readProperty[ 28] calendar,1 present-value
3856	50.307137	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 29]
3858	50.310026	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 30]
3859	50.313049	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	73	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 29]
3860	50.328264	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	76	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 30]
3861	50.330849	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 31]
3862	50.330891	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 32]
3863	50.333522	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 33]
3864	50.335645	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 34]
3865	50.335682	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 35]
3866	50.339021	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	76	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 31]
3867	50.348595	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	73	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 32]
3868	50.358397	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	73	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 33]
3869	50.361215	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	69	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 36] calendar,3 present-value
3870	50.367995	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	73	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 34]
3871	50.378005	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	78	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 35]
3872	50.386616	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	71	Complex-ACK readProperty[ 36] calendar,3 present-value
4023	51.347560	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 37]
4024	51.347615	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 38]
4025	51.351035	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 39]
4026	51.352824	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	76	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 37]
4027	51.361781	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	76	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 38]
4028	51.370900	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	72	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 39]
4029	51.373532	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 40]
4030	51.381002	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	73	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 40]
4035	51.386834	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 41]
4036	51.386881	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	71	Confirmed-REQ readPropertyMultiple[ 42]
4037	51.395440	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	72	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 41]
4038	51.405290	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	73	Complex-ACK readPropertyMultiple[ 42]
4039	51.407954	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	69	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 43] calendar,1 present-value
4040	51.414282	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	71	Complex-ACK readProperty[ 43] calendar,1 present-value
4261	53.164590	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	64	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 44] device,194235 description
4264	53.173172	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	66	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 45] device,194235 object-list
4392	53.603992	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	60	Abort other[ 44]
5496	59.208284	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	64	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 44] device,194235 description
5497	59.208431	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	66	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 45] device,194235 object-list
5579	59.615817	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	60	Abort other[ 44]
5935	65.218619	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	64	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 44] device,194235 description
5936	65.218697	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	66	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 45] device,194235 object-list
5950	65.628316	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	60	Abort other[ 44]

awald · March 27, 2023, 11:10pm

This is the packet trace when reading from the Temco tool. Both devices are populating

762	5.866625	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	UDP	109	1234 → 57619 Len=67
877	6.367589	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	UDP	109	1234 → 57619 Len=67
936	6.868972	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	UDP	182	1234 → 57619 Len=140
1650	9.956393	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	ICMP	74	Echo (ping) request id=0x0001, seq=13357/11572, ttl=10 (reply in 1651)
1651	9.961965	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	ICMP	74	Echo (ping) reply id=0x0001, seq=13357/11572, ttl=10 (request in 1650)
1665	10.127104	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.255	BACnet-APDU	75	Unconfirmed-REQ i-Am device,192288
1704	10.371371	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.255	BACnet-APDU	70	Unconfirmed-REQ i-Am device,194235
1744	10.836364	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	69	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[240] device,192288 protocol-services-supported
1745	10.837628	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	64	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[241] device,194235 protocol-services-supported
1752	10.846303	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	77	Complex-ACK readProperty[240] device,192288 protocol-services-supported
1753	10.850004	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	69	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 13] device,192288 protocol-services-supported
1756	10.858843	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	64	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 15] device,194235 protocol-services-supported
1757	10.864190	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	77	Complex-ACK readProperty[ 13] device,192288 protocol-services-supported
1764	10.999049	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	ICMP	74	Echo (ping) request id=0x0001, seq=13358/11828, ttl=10 (reply in 1765)
1765	11.005296	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	ICMP	74	Echo (ping) reply id=0x0001, seq=13358/11828, ttl=10 (request in 1764)
1796	11.374146	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.255	BACnet-APDU	72	Complex-ACK readProperty[241] device,194235 protocol-services-supported
1852	11.824313	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	73	Confirmed-REQ confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 1] V=260 SN=1
1856	11.873695	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	70	Unconfirmed-REQ i-Am device,194235
1910	12.386364	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	473	Complex-ACK confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 1] V=260 SN=1
1920	12.432419	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	73	Confirmed-REQ confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 2] V=260 SN=1
1988	12.883831	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	271	Complex-ACK confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 2] V=260 SN=1
1991	12.948090	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	73	Confirmed-REQ confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 3] V=260 SN=1
2006	13.389776	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	441	Complex-ACK confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 3] V=260 SN=1
2011	13.508378	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	73	Confirmed-REQ confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 4] V=260 SN=1
2017	13.886277	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	441	Complex-ACK confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 4] V=260 SN=1
2042	14.007413	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	73	Confirmed-REQ confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 5] V=260 SN=1
2099	14.387242	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	493	Complex-ACK confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 5] V=260 SN=1
2101	14.396639	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	73	Confirmed-REQ confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 6] V=260 SN=1
2111	14.884488	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	176	Complex-ACK confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 6] V=260 SN=1
2114	14.957658	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	73	Confirmed-REQ confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 7] V=260 SN=1
2119	15.386837	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	171	Complex-ACK confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 7] V=260 SN=1
2572	16.873488	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	69	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[240] device,192288 protocol-services-supported
2573	16.873517	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	64	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[241] device,194235 protocol-services-supported
2579	16.885003	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	77	Complex-ACK readProperty[240] device,192288 protocol-services-supported
2585	16.890581	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	69	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 13] device,192288 protocol-services-supported
2589	16.890766	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	64	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 15] device,194235 protocol-services-supported
2593	16.902960	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	77	Complex-ACK readProperty[ 13] device,192288 protocol-services-supported
2615	16.953633	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.255	BACnet-APDU	75	Unconfirmed-REQ i-Am device,192288
2724	17.389403	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.255	BACnet-APDU	70	Unconfirmed-REQ i-Am device,194235
2795	17.767289	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	64	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 19] device,194235 protocol-services-supported
2796	17.767425	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	69	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[246] device,192288 protocol-services-supported
2797	17.767518	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	64	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[247] device,194235 protocol-services-supported
2798	17.768594	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	69	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 20] device,192288 protocol-services-supported
2799	17.783132	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	77	Complex-ACK readProperty[246] device,192288 protocol-services-supported
2810	17.799507	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	77	Complex-ACK readProperty[ 20] device,192288 protocol-services-supported
2832	17.953870	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	73	Confirmed-REQ confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 8] V=260 SN=1
2845	18.394779	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	473	Complex-ACK confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 8] V=260 SN=1
2847	18.407261	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	73	Confirmed-REQ confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 9] V=260 SN=1
2928	18.898956	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	533	Complex-ACK confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 9] V=260 SN=1
2939	19.021704	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	73	Confirmed-REQ confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 10] V=260 SN=1
3007	19.400043	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	533	Complex-ACK confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 10] V=260 SN=1
3046	19.517919	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	73	Confirmed-REQ confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 11] V=260 SN=1
3103	19.901726	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	533	Complex-ACK confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 11] V=260 SN=1
3112	20.018499	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	73	Confirmed-REQ confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 12] V=260 SN=1
3158	20.402111	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	533	Complex-ACK confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 12] V=260 SN=1
3182	20.517652	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	73	Confirmed-REQ confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 13] V=260 SN=1
3263	20.902441	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	533	Complex-ACK confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 13] V=260 SN=1
3291	21.013742	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	73	Confirmed-REQ confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 14] V=260 SN=1
3316	21.402886	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	533	Complex-ACK confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 14] V=260 SN=1
3455	21.526348	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	73	Confirmed-REQ confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 15] V=260 SN=1
4105	21.898887	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	255	Complex-ACK confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 15] V=260 SN=1
4572	22.704172	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	73	Confirmed-REQ confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 16] V=260 SN=1
4574	22.879885	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	69	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[240] device,192288 protocol-services-supported
4575	22.879898	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	64	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[241] device,194235 protocol-services-supported
4581	22.890290	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	77	Complex-ACK readProperty[240] device,192288 protocol-services-supported
4582	22.901863	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	69	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 13] device,192288 protocol-services-supported
4586	22.902023	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	64	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 15] device,194235 protocol-services-supported
4591	22.907379	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	271	Complex-ACK confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 16] V=260 SN=1
4593	22.919985	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	77	Complex-ACK readProperty[ 13] device,192288 protocol-services-supported
4594	23.048999	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	73	Confirmed-REQ confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 17] V=260 SN=1
4617	23.403732	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	271	Complex-ACK confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 17] V=260 SN=1
4654	23.788087	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	69	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[246] device,192288 protocol-services-supported
4655	23.788118	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	64	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[247] device,194235 protocol-services-supported
4660	23.795707	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	77	Complex-ACK readProperty[246] device,192288 protocol-services-supported
4661	23.810101	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	64	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 19] device,194235 protocol-services-supported
4662	23.810174	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	69	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 20] device,192288 protocol-services-supported
4663	23.825097	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	77	Complex-ACK readProperty[ 20] device,192288 protocol-services-supported
5209	29.793162	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	69	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[246] device,192288 protocol-services-supported
5210	29.793245	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	64	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[247] device,194235 protocol-services-supported
5215	29.800665	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	77	Complex-ACK readProperty[246] device,192288 protocol-services-supported
5216	29.824849	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	64	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 19] device,194235 protocol-services-supported
5217	29.825095	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	69	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 20] device,192288 protocol-services-supported
5220	29.839234	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	77	Complex-ACK readProperty[ 20] device,192288 protocol-services-supported
5311	30.924992	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	UDP	109	1234 → 57619 Len=67
5370	31.423020	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	UDP	109	1234 → 57619 Len=67
5375	31.917871	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	UDP	182	1234 → 57619 Len=140
6647	37.705490	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	73	Confirmed-REQ confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 18] V=260 SN=1
6688	37.929239	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	271	Complex-ACK confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 18] V=260 SN=1
6722	38.052078	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	73	Confirmed-REQ confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 19] V=260 SN=1
6782	38.430456	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	271	Complex-ACK confirmedPrivateTransfer[ 19] V=260 SN=1

awald · March 27, 2023, 11:12pm

This is what it looks like from yabe which is also populating both devices

2876	13.028686	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	UDP	109	1234 → 57619 Len=67
2929	13.525593	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	UDP	109	1234 → 57619 Len=67
2969	14.026852	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	UDP	182	1234 → 57619 Len=140
3256	17.056677	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	75	Unconfirmed-REQ i-Am device,192288
3287	17.142372	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	69	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 2] device,192288 object-name
3288	17.151992	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	77	Complex-ACK readProperty[ 2] device,192288 object-name
3384	17.533180	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	70	Unconfirmed-REQ i-Am device,194235
3386	17.534991	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	64	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 6] device,194235 object-name
3457	18.034000	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	76	Complex-ACK readProperty[ 6] device,194235 object-name
3470	18.063938	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	75	Unconfirmed-REQ i-Am device,192288
3543	18.538144	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	70	Unconfirmed-REQ i-Am device,194235
3604	19.074722	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	75	Unconfirmed-REQ i-Am device,192288
3696	19.539853	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	70	Unconfirmed-REQ i-Am device,194235
6900	36.725981	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	64	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 7] device,194235 object-list
6949	37.078074	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	294	Complex-ACK readProperty[ 7] device,194235 object-list device,194235 analog-value,1 analog-value,2 analog-value,3 analog-input,1 analog-input,2 analog-input,3 analog-input,4 analog-input,5 analog-input,6 analog-input,7 analog-input,8 analog-input,9 analog-input,10 analog-input,11 analog-input,12 analog-input,13 analog-output,2 analog-output,3 analog-output,4 analog-output,5 analog-output,6 analog-output,7 analog-output,8 analog-output,9 binary-output,1 schedule,1 schedule,2 schedule,3 schedule,4 schedule,5 schedule,6 schedule,7 schedule,8 calendar,1 calendar,2 calendar,3 calendar,4 (128) Vendor Proprietary Value,1 (128) Vendor Proprietary Value,2 (128) Vendor Proprietary Value,3 (128) Vendor Proprietary Value,4 (128) Vendor Proprietary Value,5 multi-state-value,0 multi-state-value,1 multi-state-value,2
6957	37.097226	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	64	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 8] device,194235 structured-object-list
7053	37.573696	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	60	Error readProperty[ 8]
8568	41.073066	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	69	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 9] device,192288 object-list
8569	41.091062	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	299	Complex-ACK readProperty[ 9] device,192288 object-list device,192288 binary-value,1 binary-value,2 binary-value,3 analog-input,1 analog-input,2 analog-input,3 analog-input,4 analog-input,5 analog-input,6 analog-input,7 analog-input,8 analog-output,11 analog-output,12 analog-output,13 analog-output,14 binary-output,1 binary-output,2 binary-output,3 binary-output,4 binary-output,5 binary-output,6 binary-output,7 binary-output,8 binary-output,9 binary-output,10 schedule,1 schedule,2 schedule,3 schedule,4 schedule,5 schedule,6 schedule,7 schedule,8 calendar,1 calendar,2 calendar,3 calendar,4 (128) Vendor Proprietary Value,1 (128) Vendor Proprietary Value,2 (128) Vendor Proprietary Value,3 (128) Vendor Proprietary Value,4 (128) Vendor Proprietary Value,5 multi-state-value,0 multi-state-value,1 multi-state-value,2
8570	41.093574	192.168.3.41	192.168.3.5	BACnet-APDU	69	Confirmed-REQ readProperty[ 10] device,192288 structured-object-list
8571	41.099119	192.168.3.5	192.168.3.41	BACnet-APDU	64	Error readProperty[ 10]