Hi everybody,
With the semantic and non-semantic idea in mind, a group of people around me are setting up our homes currently as good as possible which only now happens to become very user-friendly via the new UI.
However, we have been struggling with using SEMANTIC and NON-SEMANTIC groups within the tree because some of the items (or group) “suddenly” disappeared. It took us a while to find out when it is happening, so we put this together which I try to document below. The main question then is why this is happening and whether and if why this is maybe intended.
Let me explain our usecase:
we have the following setup in a semantic way
- a house
- first floor
- second floor
- room1
- Group Rollershutters Room1
- other items
- room2
- Group Rollershutters Room2
- other items
- third floor
of course we also have rollershutters in the first floor in several rooms which I didn’t document here for brevity reasons…
All of the above are semantic items and groups
Now we define non-semantic groups, so we can control the Rollershutters in a hierarchical way. Note that the intention is to reuse our semantic RS groups that we already have in our rooms to avoid recreating them.
- RS all (non-semantic)
- RS first floor (non-semantic)
- RS second floor
- Group Rollershutters Room1 (semantic)
- Group Rollershutters Room2
- RS third floor
So
- “Group Rollershutters Room1” has two parents: “room1” and “RS second floor”
- “Group Rollershutters Room2” has two parents: “room2” and “RS second floor”
And from a control standpoint this works pretty well. We can control “RS all” together or “RS second floor” at once. All good BUT there is a display issue in the tree of the UI
We basically have two roots, one semantic and the other non-semantic. The first tree is completely shown as depicted above but the second tree HIDES the semantic groups which is kind of sad. It is only showing that the following way
- RS all (non-semantic)
- RS first floor (non-semantic)
- RS second floor
- RS third floor
Note that if you click in “RS second floor” and go to the edit mode, you of course see its sub-childs or groups.
As the behaviour is actually a bit hindering managing the groups like that as you cannot use the tree to navigate and have an easy overview of the non-semantic structure, our question is:
Is there a good reason not to show the semantic groups in the non-semantic group items or would it be possible to show them?
Additionally there is a small wish: unfortunately the checkbox “non-semantic items” is not kept. Can we make it sticky?
Thanks for all you great work and we are looking forward to understand the above behaviour.
Stefan