Giving up dynamic pricing in Winter 26/27

I created a blog entry why im switching from dynamic pricing to fixed pricing in winter 26/27.
Maybe worth reading for some people.

That switch makes sense for winter, when the risk is concentrated in a few expensive evening hours and there is little solar to offset them. Before locking in, I would compare the full winter bill, including fixed fees and grid charges, rather than just the energy price, since those parts do not change with the tariff. It is also worth checking how easily you can switch back in spring, so a fixed winter rate does not keep you from cheaper dynamic prices when days get longer again.

I did include den fixed parts as well and it still comes out cheaper to switch.

The main reason I struggle a bit to go to the fixed rate ist that the contract will be one year.

That one-year point is the key hesitation for me too, because a full-year fixed contract also gives up the spring and summer upside when dynamic prices are usually much kinder. Before signing, I would check both the early-exit cost and what rate applies once the year ends, since an automatic rollover can quietly undo the winter saving. If those terms look harsh, a shorter fixed term or a capped tariff could give most of the winter protection without locking away the cheaper months.

Does it?

This is a home automation forum, isn’t it.
Here we share solutions how to pre-heat in cheap times and to block heating in those most expensive evening times.

This is my live bill of this month. Those savings are mostly from HEMS overriding heat pump run times (no EV), plus by cheapmost charging battery from grid ahead of consumption.
The reference value my cost is compared to is the day-ahead prices, weighted with a standard consumption profile so those savings.
Note values include network charges, taxes etc, they amount to ~20 ct.
Savings are just from the genuine power price so in terms of %, that would be about 21 % savings in comparison if I’m not mistaken.

My openHAB based energy management system (HEMS) doesn’t even leverage the full potential yet, I’ve only recently begun to AI-optimize the algorithms.
There’s also an interesting thread over at Thread for discussing money saved with OpenHAB - #31 by masipila

Bottom line: the dynamic power tariff is key and prerequisite to all of these savings.

PS
I’m commercially offering my HEMS, too. You can get a free trial at https://storm.house/download-ems . It contains plain readable openHAB rules if interested.

I got quite lucky for this winter and got a ridiculously cheap contract from the beginning of October 2026 until the end of March 2027.

In Finland we have basically three kinds of contracts:

  • Spot price / dynamic prices
  • Fixed price contracts typically for 6 / 12 / 24 months
  • Hybrid contracts with a base price X c/kWh +/- delta

The “delta” in the last contract is checked for each month so that your weighted average price is compared against that month’s average spot price. In plain English: if you consume electricity when it’s cheaper than the month’s average, your delta will be negative and you will get discount. If you consume during times which are more expensive than the month’s average, the delta will be positive and you end up paying more.

Now, I discussed about the different contract types with a friend of mine in April and he mentioned that the company where he has the contract has a practice that old customers can make a fixed-price contract but postpone the start date of the contract by up to 6 months to the future. In other words, you can fix the price now but only start that contract half a year later.

That company happened to acquire the company where I had my (spot priced) contract. So I checked in April what kind of fixed price & hybrid contracts they have available. It turned out that they had a hybrid contract for 6 months at 6.3 c/kWh, which I believe they had calculated for the summer months (April - October).

I asked from their customer service if it’s possible to get that contract but postpone it by 6 months and it turned out to be possible. So I made that deal from the beginning of October until the end of March.

We can schedule most of our consumption to the cheapest times of the day with openHAB Spot Price Optimizer. Which means that our “delta” is always negative and the more the prices fluctuate during the month, the bigger the negative delta is for our household. A typical month is that we’re -30% … - 50% below the monthly spot average so if the monthly spot average would be for example 10 c/kWh, our delta would be -3 … -5 c/kWh. So we would end up paying 6.3 - 3 = 3.3 c / kWh … 6.3 - 5 = 1.3 c/kWh in that scenario.

This October was much cheaper in the spot market than what the futures indicated. The futures were estimating ~10 c/kWh price levels but the actual so far is 4.18 c/kWh because it has been very windy. If we would have had a spot contract, we would be at 2.34 c/kWh so our delta is -1.76 c/kWh. In yet another words, we will pay about 4.5 c/kWh for October i.e. the spot priced contract would have been cheaper still this month.

The futures for Nov-Dec are 11 c/kWh at the moment, Jan-Feb are about 15 c/kWh and March is about 10.5 c/kWh. With a -30% delta, we would end up to -3 … -4.5 c/kWh discount from the 6.3 c/kWh base price i.e. 1.8 … 3.3 c/kWh.

Cheers,
Markus

p.s. At the moment the provider is offering the 6 month hybrid contracts at 13.38 c/kWh and my understanding is that they have changed their processes so that existing customers can postpone the contract start only by 3 months.

I did sign already after i made my calculations.
I think even if the prices are better than the current outlook, it will be marginal.
Next year in November i can see if i gambled bad.

that sound really nice actually. Here its usually the variable tariffs with one month contract or 12/24.
I settled now with the 12 months contract for 9,99 cent/kWh.

BTW i have a PR open that might be of interest for you: [optimalwindow] Initial contribution by tl-photography · Pull Request #21896 · openhab/openhab-addons · GitHub

I checked the futures and it does look pretty bad, at least in Austria.

I currently don’t see that i can beat the 9,99 c/kWh contract with that prices, when they might come. And even if i beat them, it will be not by a big margin.

That sounds like a sensible call once you have run the numbers, and locking in for winter removes the worst of the evening-price risk. Your November review point next year is a good one too, since by then you will have a full winter of actual bills to compare against the dynamic alternative. I hope the fixed rate works out as calculated, and it will be interesting to hear how that comparison looks in a year.

Do you have to pay an availability charge for electricity in other countries?

Here in Australia even if I don’t use ANY power from the grid I still get charged about $2.70 per DAY and over the 90 day billing cycle that is $243 without using any grid power.

Yes we have in Austria. Depends on the contract, but somewhere around 10€ per month or so.

Cheaper than here in Australia.

Quite expensive, that’s true