I’ve come across something very odd which I am sure did not happen in 2.5. I have various items which are updated from HABPanel. I have rules files split out into multiple files for readability each rule acts upon a different item All rules are triggered by “received update” The last file to be…

I have a similar problem, not sure about the root-cause or how to fix it: Rule does not work dependent on position in rule file - #5 by rlkoshak I was linked to this threat (obviously bad search on my side; sorry!). I have no single " Member of trigger", hence I can exclude this. If the topics are …

Has this been cleared up a bit more anywhere? I am running into a similar situation where my rules are not triggering. These rules are imported into a new install of OH3 from OH2 so I know they were working. I can get them to trigger if I play around with the files, put the rules in individual fil…

Dear dot850, unfortunately I can not give you any advise. I was hoping that an update fixes this! Nevertheless it proves something setup-independent is going wrong. Anybody out there who can help to fix this? Thanks and best!

“me too” doesn’t move us much further along. It is possible to create symptoms like non-triggering rules by having duplicate rule “names”. It is possible to create symptoms like non-triggering rules by having invisible control characters in the text. (That can give many and various errors,or silen…

I have the same behavior here. Now, I also checked for duplicate rule names and found two matches. I renamed those and will observe it over the next days. My setup uses jython and there are mostly @when("Item/Member of/Descendent of **** received update") rules in place.

Hi @rossko57 , I am fairly certain this isn’t a typo in the rules/items itself. Like I said, I took this directly from an Openhab2 instance, and I’ve run into this issue in a few different places. Just to be clear, some rules run just fine! That being said, I would love to try to nail down the issu…

Okay, follow a different investigative path with Items. Missing from your experiments is observation from your events.log. It’s be really helpful to be sure the event reaches the events bus (else rules will not trigger). An experiment of my own: Create a test logging rule triggered from complete…

I really appreciate the help. But what do you mean by another path with items? I’ve tried creating new items file and new names… Is this one of those teaching moments where you see the issue and you want me to find it myself? :smirk: I was tinkering and changed the climate2.rules to: rule "Main_D…

OH3 (Possible) DSL Rules, received update not firing from different files

Setup, Configuration and Use Scripts & Rules

Andrew_Rowe (Andrew Rowe) March 15, 2021, 1:07am 31

please see linked thread here

because was nasty buggy and may not be fully flushed out, sounds same ish
see github issue in linked thread