Popp CO sensor 004407 not reporting burglar alarm

The sensor is not reporting the burglar alarm for the alarm channel. It does report when the burglar alarm is reset.

However, the burglar alarm is reported as a SENSOR_BINARY_REPORT. But the reset of the burglar alarm will not update sensor_binary channel.

I have no idea how to solve this. I am a bit concerned that the device would not report a CO alarm as well.

Found it. I needed to change alarm_burglar to alarm_tamper in the database. The event types are now hardcoded in the binding :frowning:

Is there a chance that https://www.cd-jackson.com/index.php/zwave/zwave-device-database/openhab-2-channel-types is updated. It is missing alarm_tamper and has no information which event types are mapped to the channel type.

Here’s a list of things which may as well be affected. Without the corresponding zwave xml file I can’t however even provide a guess which things report event=3 and thus need to be classified as alarm_tamper.

thing/aeon/zw122_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/aeon/zw097_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/isurpass/dx1wl_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/oomi/oomimultisensor_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/oomi/ft100_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/heiman/hs1msz_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/heiman/m4172_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/ge/26933_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/fibaro/fgcd001_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/fibaro/fgbs222_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/idlock/idl150_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/idlock/idl101_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/wintop/wtrfid_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/elexa/dmdp1_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/zwaveme/hs1ds_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/devolo/phpse02_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/devolo/mt2755_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/devolo/09813_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/devolo/mt2756_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/zipato/nenaspd01z_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/zipato/zp3102_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/zipato/keypad_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/zipato/hmhs1wlz_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/vision/zf5201eu_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/vision/zd2105_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/vision/zm1621br5_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/vision/zm1601_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/vision/zm1602_15_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/vision/zg8101_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/vision/zp3102_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/vision/zs5101_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/philio/pat02b_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/philio/pat02a_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/philio/pat02c_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/philio/psp05_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/philio/pst02a_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/benext/tagreader_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/locstar/ls8015zw_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/enerwave/zwnbpc_5_10.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/channels.xml:    <channel-type id="alarm_burglar">
thing/vemmio/mt100_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/zooz/zse18_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/zooz/zse29_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/zooz/zse19_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/kwikset/914trlv3_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/kwikset/910_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/kwikset/912_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/hank/swes01_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/hank/hkzwms01_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/hank/hkzwfld01_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/eco/flfzwave5r1_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/eco/ecolinkpirv25_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/eco/tiltzwave25eco_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/qubino/zmnhnd_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar2" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/popp/700045_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/popp/005107_1_1.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/popp/700854_2_4.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/popp/009402_1_14.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/popp/004407_1_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/popp/pope700982_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/fortrezz/ssa1_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/ring/1156d_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/ring/dwss_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/everspring/sp816_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/everspring/sm810_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/steinel/l810ledihf_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/steinel/l810ledihf_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar2" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/steinel/xledhome2_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/steinel/xledhome2_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar2" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/steinel/rsledd2_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/steinel/rsledd2_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar2" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/steinel/motionswitchled_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/steinel/motionswitchled_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar1" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/steinel/is1402_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/aeotec/zwa008_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/shenzhen/motionsensorin_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/sensative/1102011_0_3.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/sensative/1102011_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/dlink/dchz310_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/ingersollecolink/dwzwave1_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/ingersollecolink/rs200_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/abus/shwm10000_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">

The Fibaro is on my list to look at. I had looked at it and thought it had issues so have not migrated the ones I have across.

When I finally get the smart implant update working fully I will pick it up.

Thanks, much appreciated.
Unfortunately I neither own the fgcd or fgbs Fibaro devices so can’t really offer support.