Popp CO sensor 004407 not reporting burglar alarm

Tags: #<Tag:0x00007f386daad4d8>

The sensor is not reporting the burglar alarm for the alarm channel. It does report when the burglar alarm is reset.

However, the burglar alarm is reported as a SENSOR_BINARY_REPORT. But the reset of the burglar alarm will not update sensor_binary channel.

I have no idea how to solve this. I am a bit concerned that the device would not report a CO alarm as well.

Found it. I needed to change alarm_burglar to alarm_tamper in the database. The event types are now hardcoded in the binding :frowning:

Is there a chance that https://www.cd-jackson.com/index.php/zwave/zwave-device-database/openhab-2-channel-types is updated. It is missing alarm_tamper and has no information which event types are mapped to the channel type.

Here’s a list of things which may as well be affected. Without the corresponding zwave xml file I can’t however even provide a guess which things report event=3 and thus need to be classified as alarm_tamper.

thing/aeon/zw122_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/aeon/zw097_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/isurpass/dx1wl_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/oomi/oomimultisensor_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/oomi/ft100_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/heiman/hs1msz_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/heiman/m4172_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/ge/26933_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/fibaro/fgcd001_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/fibaro/fgbs222_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/idlock/idl150_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/idlock/idl101_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/wintop/wtrfid_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/elexa/dmdp1_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/zwaveme/hs1ds_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/devolo/phpse02_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/devolo/mt2755_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/devolo/09813_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/devolo/mt2756_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/zipato/nenaspd01z_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/zipato/zp3102_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/zipato/keypad_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/zipato/hmhs1wlz_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/vision/zf5201eu_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/vision/zd2105_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/vision/zm1621br5_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/vision/zm1601_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/vision/zm1602_15_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/vision/zg8101_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/vision/zp3102_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/vision/zs5101_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/philio/pat02b_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/philio/pat02a_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/philio/pat02c_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/philio/psp05_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/philio/pst02a_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/benext/tagreader_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/locstar/ls8015zw_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/enerwave/zwnbpc_5_10.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/channels.xml:    <channel-type id="alarm_burglar">
thing/vemmio/mt100_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/zooz/zse18_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/zooz/zse29_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/zooz/zse19_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/kwikset/914trlv3_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/kwikset/910_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/kwikset/912_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/hank/swes01_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/hank/hkzwms01_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/hank/hkzwfld01_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/eco/flfzwave5r1_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/eco/ecolinkpirv25_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/eco/tiltzwave25eco_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/qubino/zmnhnd_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar2" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/popp/700045_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/popp/005107_1_1.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/popp/700854_2_4.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/popp/009402_1_14.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/popp/004407_1_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/popp/pope700982_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/fortrezz/ssa1_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/ring/1156d_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/ring/dwss_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/everspring/sp816_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/everspring/sm810_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/steinel/l810ledihf_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/steinel/l810ledihf_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar2" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/steinel/xledhome2_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/steinel/xledhome2_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar2" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/steinel/rsledd2_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/steinel/rsledd2_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar2" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/steinel/motionswitchled_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/steinel/motionswitchled_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar1" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/steinel/is1402_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/aeotec/zwa008_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/shenzhen/motionsensorin_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/sensative/1102011_0_3.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/sensative/1102011_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/dlink/dchz310_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/ingersollecolink/dwzwave1_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/ingersollecolink/rs200_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">
thing/abus/shwm10000_0_0.xml:      <channel id="alarm_burglar" typeId="alarm_burglar">

The Fibaro is on my list to look at. I had looked at it and thought it had issues so have not migrated the ones I have across.

When I finally get the smart implant update working fully I will pick it up.

Thanks, much appreciated.
Unfortunately I neither own the fgcd or fgbs Fibaro devices so can’t really offer support.