I have a KNX-DALI-Dimmer in use. Several month ago, I was able to integrate spots in openHAB, which still works fine. I’m able to switch on/off and dim up/down the spots.
In the same way, I did for another spots. But the only thing what I can do, is switch on/off. I’m not able to dim up or down the lights, although I did the same settings.
The things are designed as follows, the first one (EG_Kueche_Spots) works:
I cannot remember, if I did some settings. The settings for both group adresses in ETS are the same. Any ideas?
In the ETS diagnose window, I can see 6/0/1 when I switch the lights on and 6/0/4 for dimming status. But no 6/0/5 when I swipe over range of 0 - 100%.
I still have this issue. I tried several things. The only thing what works, is when I add in the ETS5 the communication object of other spots to the group address of the kitchen 6/5/5, then I’m able to dim up/down the lights. But if the spot is in another group address than 6/5/5, e.g. 6/0/5, then it doesn’t work.
Perhaps there are still other settings to do in the ETS?
Type dimmer : EG_TV_Wand “TV-Zimmer Wand”
GA to switch on/off = 6/0/1,
GA for switching on/off = 6/0/4,
GA for absolute positioning = 6/0/5,
GA for relative positioning = 6/0/2
Do all these adresses work if you use them outside openHAB via KNX-switch or whatever you use?
Yes, the GAs for the TV room are exactly as you described:
6/0/1 - to switch the lights on/off
6/0/2 - to dim relative
6/0/3 - status dim value
6/0/4 - status on/off
6/0/5 - to dim absolute
All these addresses work fine within MDT KNX switches.
When I use 6/0/5, there is no log entry in the ETS Monitoring. I only see entries for 6/5/5 as if there are different settings for 6/5/5 than 6/0/5. But the are identically.
ok so no problems regarding your KNX setup as far as I can see.
The only difference to my setup with KNX dimmers is that I defined one thing per lamp with one dimmer channel and I did not set the physical adress. And another even bigger one may be that I upgraded to openHAB 3.
you did it via the openHAB web page and not via Visual Studio, right? But you configured the physical address 0/1/152 and so on… What is exactly the difference?
Pehaps I have to try with openHAB3. I’m going to upgrade it next week.
The difference is the adress "1.1.65” in the thing definition of your dimmer. But more importantly: Did you take a look in your logs? Maybe there is an easier solution before you upgrade to version 3.
I tried back and forth, but no change. I had enough.
Today I replaced openHAB with Home Assistant and it worked from the beginning. I am able to dim the brightness of the lights in TV room. I did no changes in ETS.
For now, I will try Home Assistant, which is much easier to configure btw.