If your item was defined only in Paper UI, then it will be removed after you issue the smarthome:items remove command
If you are working with *.items files, OH2 will reload the file and recreate the item immediately.
Ok, then something is broken here. All my Tellstick things and items were automatically created (not by Paper UI but by habmin, but that makes no difference, right?). Any idea where to look next? No errors in the log file…
If you see your tellstick_switch_1_13_timestamp item listed here, go to the linked channel in the Paper UI and unlink it again. Once the link is removed, the item should be gone as well.