I am building a new house and need 19 thermostats (yes 19). I liked the Honeywell WiFi Thermostats the best, but the only way to access them with OpenHab is via their cloud API via a mios Vera plugin. That plugin is no longer supported and some users report having their accounts locked for hitting the API too hard. I still have my 4 test stats running, but don’t think its a long term solution. Tho I really will miss them, I like the display, outside temp, clock via network time, etc.
I then moved to Insteon thermostats. My first one worked out, but now that I have 7 of them I am running into problems with the Insteon binding locking up (No fault of @Bernd_Pfrommer, his stuff is working great) as well as the binding not supporting state feedback. One other annoying thing is that you can’t set the clock over Insteon so I will need to manually set 19 clocks…
Today I started looking at Z-Wave thermostats, I guess they would work, but I if I make them part of my network I would need to put them on my Vera because that is where my 8 Yale dedbolts are and it does not look like they will be supported in OpenHab any time soon.
I like the Ecobee3 (not as much as my Honeywells, but better the Insteon), but it looks like the binding also requires a cloud API rather then local and I want to try to keep my home automation inside my network if I can.
Any other ideas? I don’t need anything fancy, just need single stage heat / cool since the real system is controlled by my zone controllers.
I just put in one from radiothermostat. I got the ct80 with the Wi-Fi module, but can switch to zwave if i want. That plus the multiple stages and fresh air vent had what I wanted. They sell just wifi ones cheaper. I haven’t committed to zwave yet so wanted options.
The wifi api is local to the thermostat, no internet required.
I didn’t like the Insteon options, so I have been expanding my Zwave network a bit more as of late. I am with you, the Honeywell systems look nice, but wifi to the cloud, and expensive. 19 of them, ouch.
I settled in on the CT100, which can be found for about $70 on Amazon, and have been quite happy with them. I have them wired with power from the the units they control, and that makes them great repeaters on my network. Much better, in fact, than other mains power devices I have.
There are folks playing with zwave security, but nothing solid so far. That would mean two different z-wave controllers for you if you were putting them on OpenHAB, but does the Vera have an API? Then you can still control everything from OpenHAB if you wanted to go that route. The CT100 is 100% local, no cloud.
@xsnrg, yes Vera has an API, and there is even a good openhab binding mios binding. As I mentioned my Z-Wave deadbolts are on it and then exported to OpenHab via the mios binding. I also use the IPhone location app and share locations via OpenHab.
Only thing the CT100 looks like it is missing that I am using today is Humidity. Do z-wave thermostats forward secure z-wave messages? Since I just have z-wave door locks and they don’t forward messages to save battery I had to add 4 z-wave repeters to my system so Vera could reach all of the locks. Would be nice if the thermostats filled the holes.
It would depend upon the T-Stat. I used to have Trane units, and they had Beam (ZNB) functionality to wake my door lock (I had one right next to the Kwikset).
That said, the Z-Wave lock interaction, and Z-Wave in general, got a lot better after I did the antenna hack on Vera, since it had the range to contact everything directly. I tried it using an Aeon ZWave S2, and it never had enough range to contact the lock (and hopping the Z-Wave mesh was always a little flakey, even with a dense network)
The CT-80 will support RTZW-02 ZWave USNAP modules. Not sure it is released yet I can only find them on ebay.
But this new USNAP model should support z-wave Plus (500). Since the CT-80 is not battery operated, it should always be awake and forward messages. That is my guess anyway could find a lot of details from their website.
I bough one of this thermostats and works well for the WAF (Wife Acceptance Factor), it’s a Z-wave Plus thermostat, and it’s good looking, in white. This one works even if there is any problem with your home automation, and can be started manually.
Price it’s quite high, but going down a little bit every two months.
The Z-Wave doesn’t work with AEON Stick S2, but It seems that works with the Aeon stick GEN5. (waiting for getting it)… GEN5 stick.
I’m curious about your setup. Why would you need 19 thermostats? I guess one for each room but how do you control the heater? Do you have a heating device for each room or do you have central heating devided into zones?
Im asking because I do have central heating and I am looking for a solution to control each radiator. About 12 in my house. Honeywell evohome looked interesting but appear to be quite problematic to control.
Danfoss Living Connect is a good solution for individual radiator control (if it’s compatible with your setup). But there are so many options that are dependent on your region, existing equipment, budget and objectives, that it can be very dizzying, and worthy of their own discussion threads.
Thanks for your reply. You are right and I will probably start a thread anytime soon. I had looked into Dannfos. It was a perfect solution until they changed the z-wave protocol into a closed one. At least this is the last I learned about them. But like you said, good material for a new thread.
We are in the process of integrating an OH server in HestiaPi for the next milestone (Autumn 2015). HestiaPi is a RasPi based WiFi smart thermostat for independent heating from hot water control and scheduling. If you are happy with dealing with configuring OH sitemaps etc, as its fully open source (sw and hw) you should give that a try. Feel free to ask any questions you may have or any customisation you may need. http://www.hestiapi.com/sites/default/files/styles/medium/public/IMG_5514.jpg
Everything worked and connected and I exported them all to openhab via the mios binding. That is until I woke up this morning when I saw that the vera said “Can’t Detect Device” to almost all devices including locks that had been working for months.
Regardless of what you choose for your initial solution, I have some advice. I’m building a house with 9 zones, and I’ve thought about this, too.
If your walls are still unfinished, run cat 5 or 6a to each thermostat, and have the electrician put deep boxes in the walls. You can use it as thermostat wire in the near term, and you can convert it to a PoE-powered DIY solution in the future, should you want to roll your own solution. A Raspberry Pi with a temperature and humidity sensor, an LCD, and a few buttons would suffice.
How is your system working now?
I have been remodeling my house and before the remodel started, I used a 2gig CT-100 zwave thermostat to replace the old thermostat I had. It has worked quite well with my Vera.
With my remodeling, I am getting 8 zones of radiant water-based heating. I need one thermostat per zone and am planning to keep with the 2gig. It looks nicer than the pictures of the ZTS-110. But the ZTS-110 is quite a bit cheaper. Maybe I should get ZTS-110 for the zones I will use only occasionally.
Has anybody tried both the CT-100 and the ZTS-110? Any comment as to how they compare?