The openhab-google-assistant seems abandoned compared to openhab-alexa repo. Code is a mess, issues not fixed and even simple PR are not checked and merged. Alexa is miles ahead with capabilities and supported services vs Google Assitant. I’ve forked the code, added some extra features that I need…

[image] Kim_Andersen: When some part of the development seems to be abandoned, there should be “someone” with an overview and in charge dealing with this, trying to get it up and running again, by searching for a new/more manintainers, or at least spread the word! And where do we look for the…

[image] rlkoshak: And where do we look for these developers who are not already contributing to OH? If they are already contributing then they already know and/or are choosing to volunteer their time working on something else. If they are not already contributing then how do we find them? What d…

[image] gytisgreitai: I also don’t a agree with the view that is is opensource, just let it be :slight_smile: That is not what I said and it is not what I mean. Absolutely do NOT just let it be. If you see a problem, do what is in your power to try and help fix it. But that means more than po…

[image] rlkoshak: It does no good to keep on saying the sky is falling and telling someone else what they need to do. If you see a problem, then volunteer to fix it or get involved in finding someone who can fix it. Anything else is just complaining. exactly [image] gytisgreitai: Well pr…

It is all good. If you look back, when we released the OH GA Integration there I mad an initial post and asked for contributors. It was the most seen topic and @rlkoshak and me decide to close it due it became a monster thread. I always motivate the community and highlight that everybody can help …

[image] Andrew_Rowe: @gytisgreitai it sounds like you have a done a lot of good work on the binding. Maybe you and Mehmet can collaborate on the binding or Mahmet can review your work and give you maintainers rights on the repository. Just throwing it out there. Sounds like he needs help for sur…

[image] rlkoshak: In true opensource, why don’t you volunteer yourself to try and find these developers and encourage them to contribute? You feel strongly about it. You apparently have an idea about how to make it work. You totally miss my point Rich.. One have to know there is a problem bef…

[image] Kim_Andersen: Thats why it´s important to have somekind of procedure to try deal with it. To my understanding, there is none. Then why don’t you come up with a procedure? Why don’t you figure out how to make such a procedure work? So far all of your posts are “Something’s wrong someo…

Hi @gytisgreitai , Why there isn’t the action.devices.types.LIGHT ? I see you use SWITCH for your lamp, but in this case google home don’t see a light but a switch

openHAB Community

Is google asistant integration no longer maintained?

Development Add-ons

rlkoshak (Rich Koshak) October 2, 2019, 7:26pm 60

Official Google Assistant Integration for openHAB has been reopened. I’m for anything that makes your job easier.