KNX2 Rollershutter Position behaves strangely

Add-ons Bindings
1

Hi,
I had decided to give the KNX2 Binding a second Chance and sat up my devices all new.
Using the most recent 2.4 nightly Build and a Enertex router to my KNX bus.

So far, the shutters work well but the Position Object behaves strangely:
The very second a shutter starts moving, the Position jumps to 100%. After the shutter has stopped, it then jumps to the respective (correct) value. This can be seen with different RL actuators, which are even from different Brands.

Looking a the KNX Group monitor, everything is correct. The actuator never sends anything when starting to move (eg no “100%” value) but only after stopping the respective value is sent. With only OH2 on the bus, no echos as well.

Even more strange: Within PaperUI the state of one channel gets only updated with the correct value, after I have clicked on annother rollershutter. I can’t help, but it seems there is something really broken with the rollershutter stuff in KNX2… any ideas ?

Thanks
Frank

knx.things

Bridge	knx:ip:KNXRouter "Enertex KNX/IP Router" @ "KNX" [
	type="ROUTER",
	portNumber=3671,
	readingPause=50,
	responseTimeout=10,
	readRetriesLimit=3,
	autoReconnectPeriod=1,
	localSourceAddr="1.1.55" ]
	

        {
                Thing device GENERIC "Scenes and Commands" @ "KNX" 
                {
                        Type    number-control  :               Scenes                          "Szenen"                                [ ga="17.001:0/1/0" ]
                        Type    switch  :               		Presence                        "Anwesenheit"                           [ ga="<0/0/8" ]
                        Type    switch  :               		Night                           "Nachtobjekt"                           [ ga="<0/0/12" ]
                        // Type    switch  :               		Day                             "Tagobjekt"                             [ ga="<0/0/13" ]
                        Type    switch  :               		Absence                         "Abwesenheit"                           [ ga="<0/0/14" ]
                        
                        Type    switch-control  :               ShadingHouse                    "Beschattung_Haus"                      [ ga="4/0/0" ]
                        Type    switch-control  :               ShadingEast                     "Beschattung_Ost"                       [ ga="4/0/1" ]
                        Type    switch-control  :               ShadingSouth                    "Beschattung_Sued"                      [ ga="4/0/2" ]
                        Type    switch-control  :               ShadingWest                     "Beschattung_West"                      [ ga="4/0/3" ]
                        Type    switch-control  :               ShadingAuto                     "Beschattung_Automatik"                 [ ga="4/0/15" ]
                        Type    switch-control  :               ShadingLockPosition             "Beschattung absolute Pos. sperren"     [ ga="4/0/16" ]
                        Type    switch-control  :               ShadingStateKitchenEast         "Beschattung_Status_Kueche_Ost"         [ ga="1.011:6/7/1" ]
                        Type    switch-control  :               ShadingStateLivingEast          "Beschattung_Status_Wohnen_Ost"         [ ga="1.011:6/7/2" ]
                        Type    switch-control  :               ShadingStateLivingSouth         "Beschattung_Status_Wohnen_Sued"        [ ga="1.011:6/7/3" ]
                        Type    switch-control  :               ShadingStateBalcony             "Beschattung_Status_Balkon"             [ ga="1.011:6/7/4" ]
                        Type    switch-control  :               ShadingStateBedroom             "Beschattung_Status_Schlafen"           [ ga="1.011:6/7/5" ]
                        Type    rollershutter-control  :        RSGroupHouseAll                 "RL_Haus_Alles"                         [ upDown="3/1/16", stopMove="3/2/16", position="3/2/16+3/5/16" ]
                        Type    rollershutter-control  :        RSGroupEGAll                    "RL_EG_Alles"                           [ upDown="3/1/33", stopMove="3/2/33", position="3/2/33+3/5/33" ]
                        Type    rollershutter-control  :        RSGroupOGAll                    "RL_OG_Alles"                           [ upDown="3/1/32", stopMove="3/2/32", position="3/2/32+3/5/32" ]
                        Type    rollershutter-control  :        RSGroupEastAll                  "RL_Ost_Alles"                          [ upDown="3/1/17", stopMove="3/2/17", position="3/2/17+3/5/17" ]
                        Type    rollershutter-control  :        RSGroupSouthAll                 "RL_Sued_Alles"                         [ upDown="3/1/18", stopMove="3/2/18", position="3/2/18+3/5/18" ]
                        Type    rollershutter-control  :        RSGroupWestAll                  "RL_West_Alles"                         [ upDown="3/1/19", stopMove="3/2/19", position="3/2/19+3/5/19" ]
                        Type    switch-control  :               CentralOff                      "Zentral-Aus EG"                        [ ga="0/0/4" ]
                }
               
                Thing device MEASURES "Sensor Data" @ "KNX" 
                {
                        Type    number  :       TempOutsideSouth                "Temperatur Aussen Süd"         [ ga="9.001:<11/2/20"]
                        Type    number  :       TempOutsideNorth                "Temperatur Aussen Nord"        [ ga="9.001:<11/2/22"]
                        Type    number  :       HumidityOutside                 "Feuchte Aussen Süd"            [ ga="9.001:<11/3/20"]
                        Type    number  :       TempOffice                      "Temperatur Büro"               [ ga="9.001:<11/2/7"]                        
                        Type    number  :       HumidityOffice                  "Feuchte Büro"                  [ ga="9.001:<10/0/7"]
                        Type    number  :       TempLibrary                     "Temperatur Bibliothek"         [ ga="9.001:<11/2/5"]
                        Type    number  :       TempLiving                      "Temperatur Wohnzimmer"         [ ga="9.001:<11/2/1"]
                        Type    number  :       TempSupplyroom                  "Temperatur Vorratskeller"      [ ga="9.001:<11/2/17"]
                        Type    number  :       HumiditySupplyroom              "Feuchte Vorratskeller"         [ ga="9.001:<10/0/17"]
                        Type    number  :       BrightnessEast                  "Helligkeit Ost"                [ ga="9.004:<11/1/19"]                    
                        Type    number  :       BrightnessSouth                 "Helligkeit Süd"                [ ga="9.004:<11/1/20"]
                        Type    number  :       BrightnessWest                  "Helligkeit West"               [ ga="9.004:<11/1/21"]
                        Type    number  :       Dusk                            "Dämmerung"                     [ ga="9.004:<11/1/23"]
                }

	
                Thing device SA2JUNGREG "SA2 Jung Heizkeller" @ "KNX" [ address="1.1.2", fetch=false, pingInterval=600, readInterval=0 ]
                {
                        Type    switch  :       Channel01      "Licht Küche"                   [ ga="1/1/0+<1/4/0" ]
                        Type    switch  :       Channel02      "Licht Unterschrank Nord"       [ ga="1/1/2+<1/4/2" ]
                        Type    switch  :       Channel03      "Steckdose Esse"                [ ga="2/1/0+<2/4/0" ]
                        Type    switch  :       Channel04      "Licht Unterschrank West"       [ ga="1/1/3+<1/4/3" ]
                        Type    switch  :       Channel05      "Wohnen Wandlampe West Links"   [ ga="1/1/8+<1/4/8" ]
                        Type    switch  :       Channel06      "Wohnen Wandlampe West Rechts"  [ ga="1/1/9+<1/4/9" ]
                        Type    switch  :       Channel07      "Licht Garten"                  [ ga="1/1/24+<1/4/24" ]
                        Type    switch  :       Channel08      "Licht Balkon"                  [ ga="1/1/25+<1/4/25" ]
                }

                Thing device SA3JUNGREG "SA3 Jung Heizkeller" @ "KNX" [ address="1.1.3", fetch=false, pingInterval=600, readInterval=0 ]
                {
                        Type    switch  :       Channel01      "Licht Flur UG"                 [ ga="1/1/52+<1/4/52" ]
                        Type    switch  :       Channel02      "Steckdose Heizkeller UG"       [ ga="2/1/22+<2/4/22" ]
                }

                Thing device SA3JUNGREGC "SA3 Jung (Strommessung) Heizkeller - Current" @ "KNX" [ address="1.1.3", fetch=false, pingInterval=600, readInterval=120 ]
                {
                        Type    number  :       Channel01C    "Steckdose Heizkeller UG"       [ ga="9.021:<2/2/22" ]
                }

                Thing device SA5ABBREG "SA5 ABB Unterverteilung" @ "KNX" [ address="1.1.4", fetch=false, pingInterval=600, readInterval=0 ]
                {
                        Type    switch  :       Channel01      "Licht Treppenhaus"             [ ga="1/1/18+<1/4/18" ]
                        Type    switch  :       Channel01T    "Licht Treppenhaus Zeit"        [ ga="1/0/18+<1/4/18" ]

                }

                Thing device DA1THEBENREG "DA1 Theben Dimmer Heizkeller" @ "KNX" [ address="1.1.5", fetch=false, pingInterval=600, readInterval=0 ]
                {
                        Type    dimmer  :       Channel01      "Wohnen Licht Decke Flur EG"    [ switch="1/1/4+<1/4/4", position="1/3/4+<1/5/4", increaseDecrease="1/2/4" ]
                        Type    dimmer  :       Channel02      "Wohnen Wandlampen Ost"         [ switch="1/1/45+<1/4/45", position="1/3/45+<1/5/45", increaseDecrease="1/2/45" ]
                        Type    dimmer  :       Channel03      "Licht Esstisch"                [ switch="1/1/10+<1/4/10", position="1/3/10+<1/5/10", increaseDecrease="1/2/10" ]
                }

                Thing device SA6MDTREG "SA6 MDT Unterverteilung" @ "KNX" [ address="1.1.6", fetch=false, pingInterval=600, readInterval=0 ]
                {
                        Type    switch  :       Channel01      "Steckdose Waschmaschine"       [ ga="2/1/13+<2/4/13" ]
                        Type    switch  :       Channel02      "Steckdose Trockner"            [ ga="2/1/14+<2/4/14" ]
                        Type    switch  :       Channel03      "Steckdose Geschirrspüler"      [ ga="2/1/2+<2/4/2" ]
                }

                Thing device SA6MDTREGC "SA6 MDT (Strommessung) Unterverteilung" @ "KNX" [ address="1.1.6", fetch=false, pingInterval=600, readInterval=0 ]
                {
                        Type    number  :       Channel01C    "Strom Steckdose Waschmaschine"         [ ga="9.021:<2/5/13" ]
                        Type    number  :       Channel02C    "Strom Steckdose Trockner"              [ ga="9.021:<2/5/14" ]
                        Type    number  :       Channel03C    "Strom Steckdose Geschirrspüler"        [ ga="9.021:<2/5/2" ]
                }

                Thing device SA7JUNGUP "SA7 Jung UP Bibliothek" @ "KNX" [ address="1.1.20", fetch=false, pingInterval=600, readInterval=0 ]
                {
                        Type    switch  :       Channel01      "Steckdose West"                        [ ga="1/1/26+1.011:<1/4/26" ]
                }
                
                Thing device SA8MDTUP "SA8 MDT UP Licht Gästebett und Indirekt" @ "KNX" [ address="1.1.21", fetch=false, pingInterval=600, readInterval=0 ]
                {
                        Type    switch  :       Channel01     "Licht Gästebett"                        [ ga="1/1/28+1.011:<1/4/28" ]
                        Type    switch  :       Channel02     "Indirekte Beleuchtung"                  [ ga="1/1/27+1.011:<1/4/27" ]
                }

                Thing device SA9MDTUP "SA09 MDT UP SD Bibliothek Ost" @ "KNX" [ address="1.1.22", fetch=false, pingInterval=600, readInterval=0 ]
                {
                        Type    switch  :       Channel01      "SD Bibliothek Ost"                     [ ga="2/1/17+1.011:2/4/17" ]
                } 

                Thing device SA10MDTUP "SA10 MDT UP SD Bibliothek Süd" @ "KNX" [ address="1.1.23", fetch=false, pingInterval=600, readInterval=0 ]
                {
                        Type    switch  :       Channel01      "SD Bibliothek Süd"                     [ ga="2/1/16+1.011:2/4/16" ]
                } 

                Thing device SA12MDTUP "SA12 MDT UP Licht Kellertreppe und Waschküche" @ "KNX" [ address="1.1.25", fetch=false, pingInterval=600, readInterval=0 ]
                {
                        Type    switch  :       Channel01     "Licht Kellertreppe"                     [ ga="1/1/19+<1/4/19" ]
                        Type    switch  :       Channel02     "Licht Waschküche"                       [ ga="1/1/20+<1/4/20" ]
				}
				
                Thing device SA13MDTUP "SA13 MDT UP SD WoZi Nord-Ost" @ "KNX" [ address="1.1.27", fetch=false, pingInterval=600, readInterval=0 ]
                {
                        Type    switch  :       Channel01      "Wohnen Steckdose Nord-Ost"             [ ga="2/1/3+<2/4/3" ]
                } 
                
                Thing device SA14MDTUP "SA14 MDT UP SD WoZi Süd-Ost" @ "KNX" [ address="1.1.28", fetch=false, pingInterval=600, readInterval=0 ]
                {
                        Type    switch  :       Channel01      "Wohnen Steckdose Süd-Ost"              [ ga="2/1/4+<2/4/4" ]
                } 
                
                Thing device SA15MDTUP "SA15 MDT UP SD WoZi Süd" @ "KNX" [ address="1.1.29", fetch=false, pingInterval=600, readInterval=0 ]
                {
                        Type    switch  :       Channel01      "Wohnen Steckdose Süd"                  [ ga="2/1/5+<2/4/5" ]
                }

                Thing device SA16MDTUP "SA16 MDT UP Treppenhaus" @ "KNX" [ address="1.1.31", fetch=false, pingInterval=600, readInterval=0 ]
                {
                        Type    switch  :       Channel01      "Licht Treppenhaus"                     [ ga="1/1/18+<1/4/21" ]
                        Type    switch  :       Channel01T     "Licht Treppenhaus Zeit"                [ ga="1/0/18+<1/4/21" ]
                        Type    switch  :       Channel02      "Aussenlicht Treppenhaus"               [ ga="1/1/22+<1/4/22" ] 
                        Type    switch  :       Channel03      "Licht Garage"                          [ ga="1/1/23+<1/4/23" ]
                }
                                
                Thing device SA17JUNGUP "SA17 Jung UP Treppenhaus oben" @ "KNX" [ address="1.1.32", fetch=false, pingInterval=600, readInterval=0 ]
                {
                        Type    switch  :       Channel01     "Steckdose Treppenhaus Oben"             [ ga="2/1/12+<2/4/12" ]
                }


                Thing device RA1MDTREG "RA1 MDT Rolladenaktor Heizkeller" @ "KNX" [ address="1.1.60", fetch=false, pingInterval=600, readInterval=0 ]
                {
                        Type    rollershutter  :        Channel01     "Rolladen Küche Ost"             [ upDown="3/1/1", stopMove="3/2/1", position="5.001:3/3/1+<3/5/1" ]
                        Type    rollershutter  :        Channel02     "Rolladen Wohnzimmer Ost"        [ upDown="3/1/2", stopMove="3/2/2", position="5.001:3/3/2+<3/5/2" ]
                        Type    rollershutter  :        Channel03     "Rolladen Wohnzimmer Süd"        [ upDown="3/1/3", stopMove="3/2/3", position="5.001:3/3/3+<3/5/3" ]
                        Type    rollershutter  :        Channel04     "Rolladen Balkontür"             [ upDown="3/1/4", stopMove="3/2/4", position="5.001:3/3/4+<3/5/4" ]
                }

                Thing device RA2JUNGUP "RA2 Jung Rolladenaktor UP Treppenhaus" @ "KNX" [ address="1.1.61", fetch=false, pingInterval=600, readInterval=0 ]
                {
                        Type    rollershutter  :        Channel01     "Rolladen Treppenhaus"           [ upDown="3/1/8", stopMove="3/2/8", position="5.001:3/3/8+<3/5/8" ]
                        Type    contact  :              Channel02     "Fenster Treppenhaus West"       [ ga="8/4/9" ]
                }
                
		Thing device RA3MDTUP "RA3 MDT Rolladenaktor UP Zimmer West-West" @ "KNX" [ address="1.1.62", fetch=false, pingInterval=600, readInterval=0 ]
                {
                        Type    rollershutter  :        Channel01     "Rolladen Zimmer West-West"      [ upDown="3/1/9", stopMove="3/2/9", position="5.001:3/3/9+<3/5/9" ]
                        Type    contact  :              Channel02     "Fenster Zimmer West-West"       [ ga="8/4/10" ]
                }

		Thing device RA4MDTUP "RA4 MDT Rolladenaktor UP Zimmer West-Sued" @ "KNX" [ address="1.1.63", fetch=false, pingInterval=600, readInterval=0 ]
                {
                        Type    rollershutter  :        Channel01     "Rolladen Zimmer West-West"      [ upDown="3/1/10", stopMove="3/2/10", position="5.001:3/3/10+<3/5/10" ]
                        Type    contact  :              Channel02     "Fenster Zimmer West-West"       [ ga="8/4/11" ]
		}
				
		Thing device RA5MDTUP "RA5 MDT Rolladenaktor UP Zimmer Ost-Sued" @ "KNX" [ address="1.1.64", fetch=false, pingInterval=600, readInterval=0 ]
                {
                        Type    rollershutter  :        Channel01     "Rolladen Zimmer West-West"      [ upDown="3/1/12", stopMove="3/2/12", position="5.001:3/3/12+<3/5/12" ]
                        Type    contact  :              Channel02     "Fenster Zimmer West-West"       [ ga="<8/4/13" ]
		}
                
		Thing device BE1MDT "BE1 MDT Binäreingang Heizkeller" @ "KNX" [ address="1.1.70", fetch=false, pingInterval=600, readInterval=0 ]
                {
                        Type    contact  :              Channel01     "Balkontür"                      [ ga="1.019:<8/4/0" ]
                        Type    contact  :              Channel02     "Fenster Wohnen Süd"             [ ga="1.019:<8/4/1" ]
                        Type    contact  :              Channel03     "Fenster Wohnen Ost"             [ ga="1.019:<8/4/2" ]
                        Type    contact  :              Channel04     "Fenster Küche Ost"              [ ga="1.019:<8/4/3" ]
                }

                Thing device BE2MDTUP "BE2 MDT Binäreingang UP Haustür" @ "KNX" [ address="1.1.71", fetch=false, pingInterval=600, readInterval=0 ]
                {
                        Type    switch  :       Channel01          "Treppenhaus Licht"                [ ga="1/1/18" ]
                        Type    switch  :       Channel01T         "Treppenhaus Licht Zeit"           [ ga="1/0/18" ]
                        Type    switch  :       Channel02          "Treppenhaus Licht an Haustür"     [ ga="1/1/21" ]
                        Type    switch  :       Channel02T         "Aussenlicht Zeit"                 [ ga="1/0/22" ]
                        Type    contact  :      Channel03          "Haustür Türkontakt"               [ ga="1.019:<8/4/20" ]
                        Type    contact  :      Channel04          "Garage Türkontakt"                [ ga="1.019:<8/4/28" ]
                        Type    contact  :      Channel05          "Garage Torkontakt"                [ ga="1.019:<8/4/29" ]
                        Type    switch  :       Channel06          "Garagenlicht"                     [ ga="1/1/23" ]
                }

                Thing device BE3MDTUP "BE3 MDT Binäreingang UP Waschküche" @ "KNX" [ address="1.1.72", fetch=false, pingInterval=600, readInterval=0 ]
                {
                        Type    switch  :       Channel01               "Licht Waschküche"                 [ ga="1/1/20" ]
                        Type    switch  :       Channel01T              "Kellertreppe Licht"               [ ga="1/1/18" ]
                        Type    switch  :       Channel01L              "Szene"                            [ ga="0/1/13" ]                          
                        Type    switch  :       Channel02               "Kellertreppe Licht"               [ ga="1/1/19" ]
                        Type    switch  :       Channel02T              "Kellertreppe Licht Zeit"          [ ga="1/0/19" ]
                }
                 
                Thing device BE4MDTUP "BE4 MDT Binäreingang UP Bibliothek" @ "KNX" [ address="1.1.73", fetch=false, pingInterval=600, readInterval=0 ]
                {
                        Type    switch  :       Channel01               "Licht Gästebett"                  [ ga="1/1/28" ]
                        Type    switch  :       Channel01L              "Bibliothek Alles Aus"             [ ga="2/0/4" ]                          
                }
	

                Thing device HA1MDTREG "HA1 MDT Heizungsaktor Heizkeller" @ "KNX" [ address="1.1.200", fetch=false, pingInterval=600, readInterval=0]
                {
                        Type    switch  :       Channel01         "Sommer/Winterumschaltung"          [ ga="1.001:0/0/19" ]
                        Type    switch  :       Channel02         "Heizung in Betrieb"                [ ga="1.001:<12/0/1" ]
                        Type    switch  :       Channel03         "Heizung Störung"                   [ ga="1.001:<12/0/2" ]
                        Type    number  :       Channel04         "Heizung Temperatur Wohnzimmer"     [ ga="9.001:<11/2/1" ]
                        Type    number  :       Channel05         "Heizung Betriebsartenvorwahl"      [ ga="5.005:12/6/0" ]
                        Type    number  :       Channel06         "Heizung Sollwertverschiebung"      [ ga="9.001:12/3/0" ]
                        Type    number  :       Channel07         "Heizung aktueller Sollwert"        [ ga="9.001:13/2/0" ]
                        Type    number  :       Channel08         "Heizung Wohnzimmer Stellwert"      [ ga="5.001:<13/1/0" ]
                        Type    number  :       Channel09         "Heizung Wohnzimmer Betriebsart"    [ ga="5.005:<13/6/0" ]
                }
        
                Thing device LO4MDT "LO4 MDT Wetterstation" @ "KNX" [ address="1.1.56", fetch=false, pingInterval=600, readInterval=0 ]
                {
                        Type    number  :       Channel01         "Helligkeit Ost"                    [ ga="9.004:<11/1/19" ]
                        Type    switch  :       Channel02         "Schwellwert 1 Ost"                 [ ga="1.001:<4/0/1" ]
                        // Type    switch  :       Channel03         "Schwellwert 2 Ost"                 [ ga="1.001:" ]
                        // Type    switch  :       Channel04         "Sperrobjekt Schwellwert 1 Ost"     [ ga="1.001:" ]
                        // Type    switch  :       Channel05         "Sperrobjekt Schwellwert 2 Ost"     [ ga="1.001:" ]
                        // Type    number  :       Channel06         "Rolladenposition Ost senden"       [ ga="5.001:" ]
                        // Type    switch  :       Channel07         "Fassade Sperrobjekt Ost"           [ ga="1.003:" ]
                        Type    number  :       Channel08         "Helligkeit Süd"                    [ ga="9.004:<11/1/20" ]
                        Type    switch  :       Channel09         "Schwellwert 1 Süd"                 [ ga="1.001:<4/0/2" ]
                        // Type    switch  :       Channel10         "Schwellwert 2 Süd"                 [ ga="1.001:" ]
                        // Type    switch  :       Channel11         "Sperrobjekt Schwellwert 1 Süd"     [ ga="1.001:" ]
                        // Type    switch  :       Channel12         "Sperrobjekt Schwellwert 2 Süd"     [ ga="1.001:" ]
                        // Type    number  :       Channel13         "Rolladenposition Süd senden"       [ ga="5.001:" ]
                        // Type    switch  :       Channel14         "Fassade Sperrobjekt Süd"           [ ga="1.003:" ]
                        Type    number  :       Channel15         "Helligkeit West"                  [ ga="9.004:<11/1/21" ]
                        Type    switch  :       Channel16         "Schwellwert 1 West"               [ ga="1.001:<4/0/3" ]
                        // Type    switch  :       Channel17         "Schwellwert 2 West"                 [ ga="1.001:" ]
                        // Type    switch  :       Channel18         "Sperrobjekt Schwellwert 1 West"     [ ga="1.001:" ]
                        // Type    switch  :       Channel19         "Sperrobjekt Schwellwert 2 West"     [ ga="1.001:" ]
                        // Type    number  :       Channel20         "Rolladenposition West senden"       [ ga="5.001:" ]
                        // Type    switch  :       Channel21         "Fassade Sperrobjekt West"           [ ga="1.003:" ]
                        Type    number  :       Channel22         "Dämmerung Helligkeit"             [ ga="9.004:<11/1/23" ]
                        Type    number  :       Channel23         "Windgeschwindigkeit"              [ ga="9.005:<11/6/0" ]
                        Type    number  :       Channel24         "Temperatur Aussen Ost"            [ ga="9.004:<11/2/19" ]
                        Type    switch  :       Channel25         "Nacht"                            [ ga="<0/0/12" ]
                }

rollershutter.items

// Rolläden

// Group gRL			"Rollläden Haus"		<shutter>	(All)
Group gRLEG				"Rollläden EG"		<shutter>	(All)
Group gRLDG				"Rollläden OG"		<shutter>	(All)
Group gBeschattung		"Beschattung"		<sun>		(All)
Group gRLSammelgruppe	"RL Sammelgruppen"	<shutter>	(All)
Group:Rollershutter:OR(0, 100) 	gRL 	"Rollläden [Position: %d %%]" 	<rollershutter>		(All)
Group:Switch:OR(ON, OFF) 	gRLstati 	"Beschattungen [Aktiv: %d]"	    <rollershutter>		(All)

// Rolladen EG
Rollershutter RL_Kueche_Ost			"RL Küche EG [%d %%]"			(gRLEG,gRL)	[ "Lighting" ]	{ channel="knx:device:KNXRouter:RA1MDTREG:Channel01" }
Rollershutter RL_WoZi_Ost			"RL Ost [%d %%]"				(gRLEG,gRL)	[ "Lighting" ]	{ channel="knx:device:KNXRouter:RA1MDTREG:Channel02" }
Rollershutter RL_WoZi_Sued			"RL Süd [%d %%]"				(gRLEG,gRL)	[ "Lighting" ]	{ channel="knx:device:KNXRouter:RA1MDTREG:Channel03" }
Rollershutter RL_WoZi_Balkon		"RL Balkon [%d %%]"	    		(gRLEG,gRL)	[ "Lighting" ]	{ channel="knx:device:KNXRouter:RA1MDTREG:Channel04" }

// Rolladen OG 
Rollershutter RL_Treppenhaus 		"RL Treppenhaus [%d %%]"		    (gRLDG,gRL)	[ "Lighting" ]	{ channel="knx:device:KNXRouter:RA2JUNGUP:Channel01" }
Rollershutter RL_Zimmer_West_West 	"RL Mediazimmer West [%d %%]"		(gRLDG,gRL)	[ "Lighting" ]	{ channel="knx:device:KNXRouter:RA3MDTUP:Channel01" }
Rollershutter RL_Zimmer_West_Sued 	"RL Mediazimmer Süd [%d %%]"		(gRLDG,gRL)	[ "Lighting" ]	{ channel="knx:device:KNXRouter:RA4MDTUP:Channel01" }
//Switch RL_Zimmer_West_Alle_Sperren  "RL Mediazimmer sperren"            (gRLDG,gRL)	[ "Lighting" ]	{ channel="1.001:3/7/35" }
Rollershutter RL_Zimmer_Ost_Suedt 	"RL Gästezimmer Süd [%d %%]"	    (gRLDG,gRL)	[ "Lighting" ]	{ channel="knx:device:KNXRouter:RA5MDTUP:Channel01" }
//Switch RL_Zimmer_Ost_Alle_Sperren   "RL Gästezimmer sperren"            (gRLDG,gRL)	[ "Lighting" ]	{ channel="1.001:3/7/36" }

/*
// Szenen für Rolläden
// Number Scene_RL						"Szene Rolläden"					(Szenen RL)	[ "Lighting" ]	{ channel="1.022:0/1/1" }

// Beschattungen
Switch Beschattung_Haus				        "Beschattung Haus"				    (gBeschattung)	        { channel="1.001:4/0/0" }
Switch Beschattung_Ost				        "Beschattung Ost"				    (gBeschattung)	        { channel="1.001:4/0/1" }
Switch Beschattung_Sued				        "Beschattung Süd"				    (gBeschattung)	        { channel="1.001:4/0/2" }
Switch Beschattung_West				        "Beschattung West"				    (gBeschattung)	        { channel="1.001:4/0/3" }
Switch Beschattung_Automatik		        "Beschattung sperren"			    (gBeschattung)          { channel="1.001:4/0/15" }
Switch Beschattung_Absolute_Pos_Sperren		"Position Sperren"		    	    (gBeschattung)          { channel="1.001:4/0/16" }
Switch Beschattung_Zimmer_West_Sperren      "Beschattung Media sperren"         (gBeschattung)          { channel="1.001:3/0/39" }
Switch Beschattung_Zimmer_Ost_Sperren       "Beschattung Gäste sperren"         (gBeschattung)          { channel="1.001:3/0/40" }

// Beschattung Stati
Switch Beschattung_Status_Kueche_Ost		"Beschattung Küche Ost"  	    (gRLstati)              { channel="1.011:6/7/1" }
Switch Beschattung_Status_Wohnen_Ost		"Beschattung Wohnen Ost"	    (gRLstati)              { channel="1.011:6/7/2" }
Switch Beschattung_Status_Wohnen_Sued		"Beschattung Wohnen Süd"	    (gRLstati) 	            { channel="1.011:6/7/3" }
Switch Beschattung_Status_Wohnen_Balkon		"Beschattung Balkon"		    (gRLstati)              { channel="1.011:6/7/4" }
Switch Beschattung_Status_Schlafen			"Beschattung Schlafen"	    	(gRLstati)              { channel="1.011:6/7/5" }
Switch Beschattung_Status_Zimmer_West_Sued	"Beschattung Media Süd"     	(gRLstati)              { channel="1.011:6/7/10" }
Switch Beschattung_Status_Zimmer_Ost_Sued	"Beschattung Gäste Süd"	        (gRLstati)              { channel="1.011:6/7/12" }

// Sammelgruppen 
Rollershutter RL_Haus_Alles			"RL Haus [%d %%]"		    (gRLSammelgruppe)	        { channel="1.008:3/1/16+5.001:3/5/3,3/2/16" }
Rollershutter RL_EG_Alles			"RL Unten [%d %%]"		    (gRLSammelgruppe)	        { channel="1.008:3/1/33+5.001:3/5/3,3/2/33" }
Rollershutter RL_Zimmer_West_Alles  "RL Mediazimmer [%d %%]"    (gRLSammelgruppe)	        { channel="1.008:3/1/35+5.001:3/5/10,3/2/35" }
Rollershutter RL_Zimmer_Ost_Alles	"RL Gäste [%d %%]"		    (gRLSammelgruppe)	        { channel="1.008:3/1/36+5.001:3/5/12,3/2/36" }
Rollershutter RL_OG_Alles			"RL Oben [%d %%]"		    (gRLSammelgruppe)	        { channel="1.008:3/1/32+5.001:3/5/8,3/2/32" }
Rollershutter RL_Ost_Alles			"RL Ost [%d %%]"	    	(gRLSammelgruppe)	        { channel="1.008:3/1/17+5.001:3/5/3,3/2/17" }
Rollershutter RL_Sued_Alles			"RL Süd [%d %%]"		    (gRLSammelgruppe)	        { channel="1.008:3/1/18+5.001:3/5/3,3/2/18" }
Rollershutter RL_West_Alles			"RL West [%d %%]"		    (gRLSammelgruppe)       	{ channel="1.008:3/1/19+5.001:3/5/8,3/2/19" }
*/
2

Sounds like a job for autoupdate=“false” on affected Items? (where you have real position feedback available from the device, and don’t want OH guessing a new value in response to a command)

3

Thanks for the super quick response. I totally missinterpreted the way autoupdate works, so never considered this as the solution. It works now as expected, thanks a thousand times.

4

It looks like I’m having the same issue. My configuration looks like:

knx.things:

    Thing device ja_1_2_6 "1.2.6 Jalousieaktor" @ "D0UV Unterverteilung OG/DG" [
        address = "1.2.6"
    ] {
        Type rollershutter : O1_Schlafen_Rolladen_Fenster_SO "O1_Schlafen_Rolladen_Fenster_SO" [ upDown="3/3/20", stopMove="3/3/21", position="5:001:3/3/22+<4/3/22" ]
        Type string        : O1_Schlafen_Rolladen_Fenster_SO_Diagnosetext "O1_Schlafen_Rolladen_Fenster_SO_Diagnosetext" [ ga="<4/3/23" ]
    }

knx.items

Rollershutter O1_Schlafen_Rolladen_Fenster_SO "Rolladen Fenster SO [%s%% zu]" (O1_Schlafen, gRollaeden) { channel = "knx:device:bridge:ja_1_2_6:O1_Schlafen_Rolladen_Fenster_SO", autoupdate = "false" }
String O1_Schlafen_Rolladen_Fenster_SO_Diagnosetext "Rolladen Fenster SO [%s]" (O1_Schlafen, gRollaeden) { channel = "knx:device:bridge:ja_1_2_6:O1_Schlafen_Rolladen_Fenster_SO_Diagnosetext" }

I have the same issue - when I don’t use “autoupdate=false”, the position immediately jumps after pressing Up/Down. As soon as I add “autoupdate=false” the position does not jump anymore immediately, however it also does not update to the state that the actor sends (on GA 4/3/22).

Any ideas?

BTW: This is a recently upgraded openHAB 2.4

5

Just an idea: remove the blanks

from
{ channel = "knx:device:bridge:ja_1_2_6:O1_Schlafen_Rolladen_Fenster_SO", autoupdate = "false" }
 
to
```
{ channel="knx:device:bridge:ja_1_2_6:O1_Schlafen_Rolladen_Fenster_SO",autoupdate="false" }
```

as I have encontered a couple of strange effects which have been caused by blanks in the wrong position…
(I remember that there has been a change in 2.3, if I’m not wrong)

6

Thanks for the idea! I tried removing blanks in item definiton as well as in the thing definition - no change :frowning:

7

I solved it - adding a read interval to the KNX Thing helped. As soon as I do that it regularly reads the status (as expected), but it also starts processing the status messages that are actively sent by the actors immediately.

I think this should not be necessary as reading the actors is technically not required.

8

Interesting to know. My read intervall is zero, still it works as expected. What model is your rollershutter actuator please? I am using the 8 channel MDT model.

9

MDT here, too! But also if I was sending the value via ETS I was not getting it updated correctly in OpenHAB (before making the change as described above).

10

I have seen some knx values not getting read by the oh2 side as well, since I moved to the knx 2 binding. In most cases (but not all) a complete restart of the oh2 server solved that as well. No idea why some values are entirely ignored. Good to know you found a working solution for your installation.

Happy new year :wink:

11

Out of curiousity: what did you set your read intervall to, please?

12

I set it to 3600