[OH3] problem with multiple rule files

fuetti · December 30, 2020, 8:16pm

Platform information:
- Hardware: x86 HyperV VM
- OS: Windows Server
- Java Runtime Environment: zulu 11
- openHAB version: 3.0.0
Issue of the topic:

I have severale rule files containing different kind of rules and many of them where broken after update to 3.0 - mainly because the change of time types and persistance type of contact and switched (float to int).

After I fixed this errors I noticed that in openhab.log there are logs missing. After little more debugging I found out, that I only see log entries in openhab.log from the rules file that was changed at last.

After I merged the content of two rule files in one both log entries startet to apprear in the log and seemto be executed normally. Other rules, that are still in a separate file are not executed.

For me this seems like a bug when using more than onle rule file!

Also it seems that I also get displayed the rules in the UI which are in the rules file that was changed last!

Can anyone confirm or disconfirm this behavior with OH3?

fuetti · January 1, 2021, 4:01pm

/bump - anyone else expeting this too? I am wondering what the source could be, if its only me having this problem?

ChrisSc · January 1, 2021, 7:24pm

Here’s an issue filed in openhab-core which seems to be related:

github.com/openhab/openhab-core

OH3.0.0 stable: DSL Rules are removed after reload of other .rules and .items files with same file prefix

opened 08:33PM - 28 Dec 20 UTC

closed 01:29PM - 06 Jan 21 UTC

petrows

I have issue similar to #1829 , but with different behavior: My setup * Setu…p completely made from files configuration (.rules and .things files) * Version: Openhab 3.0.0, run in docker * Full config in github: https://github.com/petrows/smarthome-openhab Problems * Reload of rules DSL file may remove all other rules from other files matching the pattern `name-XXX.rules`, e.g. reloading of `light.rules` file also removes rules from files `light-astrocolor.rules` and `light-sunrize.rules` * Reload of items files with same name as rules files may remove rules from this file, e.g. reloading of `heating.items` removes all rules from `heating.rules`. Examples how i can reproduce this: Just after start, all rules are loaded (56 rules total): ``` openhab> openhab:automation listRules ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ID UID NAME STATUS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 common-1 System started IDLE 2 common-2 Presence master IDLE 3 common-3 Waterleak IDLE 4 common-4 Test devices responce time IDLE 5 common-5 Fridge start at friday IDLE 6 common-6 Fridge stop at sunday IDLE 7 gen-1 Marina Desktop light apply color on ON IDLE 8 gen-2 Treppe Up light apply color on ON IDLE 9 gen-3 Treppe Down light apply color on ON IDLE 10 gen-4 Petro Desktop light apply color on ON IDLE 11 heating-1 Heating safe switch IDLE 12 heating-2 Heating NIGHT IDLE 13 heating-3 Heating MORNING IDLE 14 heating-4 Heating DAY IDLE 15 heating-5 Heating EVENING IDLE 16 heating-6 Auto command IDLE 17 heating-7 Heating NS boost switch IDLE 18 heating-8 Heating presense switch IDLE 19 heating-9 Heating master switch IDLE 20 light-1 Ligth master mode IDLE 21 light-10 KG Lager light changed IDLE 22 light-2 Ligth master mode status IDLE 23 light-3 Light safe switch IDLE 24 light-4 KG safe switch IDLE 25 light-5 NS follow table power IDLE 26 light-6 BZ force both lights work together IDLE 27 light-7 Sunset Rule IDLE 28 light-8 Petro desktop power IDLE 29 light-9 KG Treppe light changed IDLE 30 light-astrocolor-1 Astrocolor: Reset lamps state IDLE 31 light-astrocolor-2 Astrocolor: Set lamps color according to daytime IDLE 32 light-sunrise-1 Sinrise emulation auto off IDLE 33 light-sunrise-2 Sinrise emulation start IDLE 34 motion-1 KG Motion detect treppe IDLE 35 motion-2 KG Motion detect Lager IDLE 36 notification-1 Online notify IDLE 37 notification-2 LowBattery notify IDLE 38 notification-3 Sunset Rule 2 IDLE 39 remote-1 Spiegel control SW IDLE 40 remote-2 House verlassen SW IDLE 41 remote-3 KG Ladder BOTTOM btn IDLE 42 remote-4 KG Ladder UP btn IDLE 43 remote-5 KG Lager btn IDLE 44 remote-6 Petro desktop remote IDLE 45 remote-7 Marina desktop remote IDLE 46 remote-8 SZ remote sw IDLE 47 remote-9 KU Arbeitlicht SW IDLE 48 washmachine-1 Washmachine power IDLE 49 yeelight-1 Yeelight 1 power IDLE 50 yeelight-2 Yeelight 1 brightness IDLE 51 yeelight-3 Yeelight 1 color temp IDLE 52 yeelight-4 Yeelight 1 color IDLE 53 yeelight-5 mi-lamp-2.pws power IDLE 54 yeelight-6 mi-lamp-2.pws brightness IDLE 55 yeelight-7 mi-lamp-2.pws color temp IDLE 56 zigbee-1 Coordinator log IDLE ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ``` In ~10 seconds 4 rules are removed (52 rules left). Removed: - Astrocolor https://github.com/petrows/smarthome-openhab/tree/6a75f1eb21caacc7dfd98405fafe79a8e2d185fb/rules/light-astrocolor.rules - Sunrize: https://github.com/petrows/smarthome-openhab/tree/6a75f1eb21caacc7dfd98405fafe79a8e2d185fb/rules/light-sunrise.rules ``` openhab> openhab:automation listRules ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ID UID NAME STATUS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 common-1 System started IDLE 2 common-2 Presence master IDLE 3 common-3 Waterleak IDLE 4 common-4 Test devices responce time IDLE 5 common-5 Fridge start at friday IDLE 6 common-6 Fridge stop at sunday IDLE 7 gen-1 Marina Desktop light apply color on ON IDLE 8 gen-2 Treppe Up light apply color on ON IDLE 9 gen-3 Treppe Down light apply color on ON IDLE 10 gen-4 Petro Desktop light apply color on ON IDLE 11 heating-1 Heating safe switch IDLE 12 heating-2 Heating NIGHT IDLE 13 heating-3 Heating MORNING IDLE 14 heating-4 Heating DAY IDLE 15 heating-5 Heating EVENING IDLE 16 heating-6 Auto command IDLE 17 heating-7 Heating NS boost switch IDLE 18 heating-8 Heating presense switch IDLE 19 heating-9 Heating master switch IDLE 20 light-1 Ligth master mode IDLE 21 light-10 KG Lager light changed IDLE 22 light-2 Ligth master mode status IDLE 23 light-3 Light safe switch IDLE 24 light-4 KG safe switch IDLE 25 light-5 NS follow table power IDLE 26 light-6 BZ force both lights work together IDLE 27 light-7 Sunset Rule IDLE 28 light-8 Petro desktop power IDLE 29 light-9 KG Treppe light changed IDLE 30 motion-1 KG Motion detect treppe IDLE 31 motion-2 KG Motion detect Lager IDLE 32 notification-1 Online notify IDLE 33 notification-2 LowBattery notify IDLE 34 notification-3 Sunset Rule 2 IDLE 35 remote-1 Spiegel control SW IDLE 36 remote-2 House verlassen SW IDLE 37 remote-3 KG Ladder BOTTOM btn IDLE 38 remote-4 KG Ladder UP btn IDLE 39 remote-5 KG Lager btn IDLE 40 remote-6 Petro desktop remote IDLE 41 remote-7 Marina desktop remote IDLE 42 remote-8 SZ remote sw IDLE 43 remote-9 KU Arbeitlicht SW IDLE 44 washmachine-1 Washmachine power IDLE 45 yeelight-1 Yeelight 1 power IDLE 46 yeelight-2 Yeelight 1 brightness IDLE 47 yeelight-3 Yeelight 1 color temp IDLE 48 yeelight-4 Yeelight 1 color IDLE 49 yeelight-5 mi-lamp-2.pws power IDLE 50 yeelight-6 mi-lamp-2.pws brightness IDLE 51 yeelight-7 mi-lamp-2.pws color temp IDLE 52 zigbee-1 Coordinator log IDLE ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ``` If i will update removed file "light-astrocolor.rules" with white space change: ``` [INFO ] [el.core.internal.ModelRepositoryImpl] - Loading model 'light-astrocolor.rules' ``` Rules return back to list (only from this file - nr 30 and 31): ``` openhab> openhab:automation listRules ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ID UID NAME STATUS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 common-1 System started IDLE 2 common-2 Presence master IDLE 3 common-3 Waterleak IDLE 4 common-4 Test devices responce time IDLE 5 common-5 Fridge start at friday IDLE 6 common-6 Fridge stop at sunday IDLE 7 gen-1 Marina Desktop light apply color on ON IDLE 8 gen-2 Treppe Up light apply color on ON IDLE 9 gen-3 Treppe Down light apply color on ON IDLE 10 gen-4 Petro Desktop light apply color on ON IDLE 11 heating-1 Heating safe switch IDLE 12 heating-2 Heating NIGHT IDLE 13 heating-3 Heating MORNING IDLE 14 heating-4 Heating DAY IDLE 15 heating-5 Heating EVENING IDLE 16 heating-6 Auto command IDLE 17 heating-7 Heating NS boost switch IDLE 18 heating-8 Heating presense switch IDLE 19 heating-9 Heating master switch IDLE 20 light-1 Ligth master mode IDLE 21 light-10 KG Lager light changed IDLE 22 light-2 Ligth master mode status IDLE 23 light-3 Light safe switch IDLE 24 light-4 KG safe switch IDLE 25 light-5 NS follow table power IDLE 26 light-6 BZ force both lights work together IDLE 27 light-7 Sunset Rule IDLE 28 light-8 Petro desktop power IDLE 29 light-9 KG Treppe light changed IDLE 30 light-astrocolor-1 Astrocolor: Reset lamps state IDLE 31 light-astrocolor-2 Astrocolor: Set lamps color according to daytime IDLE 32 motion-1 KG Motion detect treppe IDLE 33 motion-2 KG Motion detect Lager IDLE 34 notification-1 Online notify IDLE 35 notification-2 LowBattery notify IDLE 36 notification-3 Sunset Rule 2 IDLE 37 remote-1 Spiegel control SW IDLE 38 remote-2 House verlassen SW IDLE 39 remote-3 KG Ladder BOTTOM btn IDLE 40 remote-4 KG Ladder UP btn IDLE 41 remote-5 KG Lager btn IDLE 42 remote-6 Petro desktop remote IDLE 43 remote-7 Marina desktop remote IDLE 44 remote-8 SZ remote sw IDLE 45 remote-9 KU Arbeitlicht SW IDLE 46 washmachine-1 Washmachine power IDLE 47 yeelight-1 Yeelight 1 power IDLE 48 yeelight-2 Yeelight 1 brightness IDLE 49 yeelight-3 Yeelight 1 color temp IDLE 50 yeelight-4 Yeelight 1 color IDLE 51 yeelight-5 mi-lamp-2.pws power IDLE 52 yeelight-6 mi-lamp-2.pws brightness IDLE 53 yeelight-7 mi-lamp-2.pws color temp IDLE 54 zigbee-1 Coordinator log IDLE ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ``` And, they are functional (reacting on command `openhab:things trigger astro:sun:home:set#event START`) with proper log messages. Here is the interesting part! Updating of file `light` removes `light-astrocolor` again: ``` [INFO ] [el.core.internal.ModelRepositoryImpl] - Loading model 'light.rules' openhab> openhab:automation listRules ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ID UID NAME STATUS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 common-1 System started IDLE 2 common-2 Presence master IDLE 3 common-3 Waterleak IDLE 4 common-4 Test devices responce time IDLE 5 common-5 Fridge start at friday IDLE 6 common-6 Fridge stop at sunday IDLE 7 gen-1 Marina Desktop light apply color on ON IDLE 8 gen-2 Treppe Up light apply color on ON IDLE 9 gen-3 Treppe Down light apply color on ON IDLE 10 gen-4 Petro Desktop light apply color on ON IDLE 11 heating-1 Heating safe switch IDLE 12 heating-2 Heating NIGHT IDLE 13 heating-3 Heating MORNING IDLE 14 heating-4 Heating DAY IDLE 15 heating-5 Heating EVENING IDLE 16 heating-6 Auto command IDLE 17 heating-7 Heating NS boost switch IDLE 18 heating-8 Heating presense switch IDLE 19 heating-9 Heating master switch IDLE 20 light-1 Ligth master mode IDLE 21 light-10 KG Lager light changed IDLE 22 light-2 Ligth master mode status IDLE 23 light-3 Light safe switch IDLE 24 light-4 KG safe switch IDLE 25 light-5 NS follow table power IDLE 26 light-6 BZ force both lights work together IDLE 27 light-7 Sunset Rule IDLE 28 light-8 Petro desktop power IDLE 29 light-9 KG Treppe light changed IDLE 30 motion-1 KG Motion detect treppe IDLE 31 motion-2 KG Motion detect Lager IDLE 32 notification-1 Online notify IDLE 33 notification-2 LowBattery notify IDLE 34 notification-3 Sunset Rule 2 IDLE 35 remote-1 Spiegel control SW IDLE 36 remote-2 House verlassen SW IDLE 37 remote-3 KG Ladder BOTTOM btn IDLE 38 remote-4 KG Ladder UP btn IDLE 39 remote-5 KG Lager btn IDLE 40 remote-6 Petro desktop remote IDLE 41 remote-7 Marina desktop remote IDLE 42 remote-8 SZ remote sw IDLE 43 remote-9 KU Arbeitlicht SW IDLE 44 washmachine-1 Washmachine power IDLE 45 yeelight-1 Yeelight 1 power IDLE 46 yeelight-2 Yeelight 1 brightness IDLE 47 yeelight-3 Yeelight 1 color temp IDLE 48 yeelight-4 Yeelight 1 color IDLE 49 yeelight-5 mi-lamp-2.pws power IDLE 50 yeelight-6 mi-lamp-2.pws brightness IDLE 51 yeelight-7 mi-lamp-2.pws color temp IDLE 52 zigbee-1 Coordinator log IDLE ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ``` Rules from `light-astrocolor` disappears again. Also, they are not reacting on trigger anymore. Please, let me know, if i can help you with some logs or something.