In winter I notice a clear split in my automations. The simple ones, like lights coming on in the evening and a gentle morning routine, get used every single day without much thought. The cleverer ones, with lots of conditions and special cases, often end up ignored or switched off when they do something unexpected. I am trying to keep things simpler this winter and focus on routines that quietly help every day. Which simple automations do you actually use every day in winter, and which clever ones have you stopped using?
With few exceptions, most of my complicated automations are over complicated because I over engineered it. Before necessarily giving up on your’s you might consider rebuilding them to see if you can make them simpler. Some techniques that can help:
- use Rule Templates and create a separate rule per “Item” instead of dealing with identifying which Item triggered the rule and finding only those Items that are relevant this time
- Break the rule up. For example, use Conditions on the rule to move stuff out of the main logic, use multiple Conditions and or multiple Actions, rules that can call, enable, or disable other rules (for example, a rule the disables all the Christmas lighting rules when a switch is toggled, and another to enable them and put all your Christmas lighting logic in those rules).
- Use libraries.
- Review triggers and conditions; are all of those strictly necessary? Maybe it’s worth the simplification to allow the rule to run more often than necessary or do redundant actions.
As for which automations I use every day in winter, these are at the top of the list:
- Alerts when a door is left open for too long (uses Threshold Alert [5.2.1;5.9.9.9] )
- Alerts when batteries are low (also uses Threshold Alert)
- Turn on the lights 30 minutes before sundown, OFF at 10:30 pm, includes Christmas lights when TisTheSeason is toggled on
- Synchronize the smart vents mode with the thermostat (i.e. change them to heating mode when the thermostat is in heating mode)
- Humidity low alerts and reminders to fill the humidifiers (also based on Threshold Alert)
- Make the “dumb” humidifier turn on and off based on the humidity measured by a near by sensor (also uses Threshold Alert)
- Alerts in the morning when the traffic is building up so we leave early on days where traffic might make us late (I’ve two rule templates for this on the marketplace but apparently Google has changed both APIs and both are broken for new users, I’m working on it but I’m also moving to n8n for this workflow but I’ll still maintain the OH rule templates).
- Turn on certain lights when my alarm goes off (at this latitude it’s dark in the morning when I get up in winter).
These are the main ones that are relevant in winter. I’ve lots of other automations that are year round I’ve not listed. I included the battery rule because when it gets cold it often kills batteries.
The door-left-open alert is the one I would keep first in winter, since it directly saves heating energy and is easy to understand when it triggers. Syncing the vents with the thermostat is another good daily winner, because it keeps rooms comfortable without a complicated set of conditions. I would also keep a simple manual override for both, so a cold evening never depends on an automation behaving perfectly.
I have a lamp that flashes when the door is left open and the front gate
It is for the garage door but it good because can’t see the door or the gate from the house but you could do similar.
I also have a wled display that shows what is left open and also displays the solar and battery through the day.
The door-left-open alert is the one I would keep too — it is simple, and it genuinely saves heating energy. I tried a fancier presence-based lighting routine last year and ended up switching it off because it kept firing at the wrong times. Rules I can explain to the rest of the household win every time.