the-ninth
February 3, 2023, 4:41pm
15
the-ninth:
Another small issue I have found is that it seems the volume channel of the Echo thing does not get updated if I change the volume via the Sonos binding or the Sonos app. But when using the speak channel while playing music, the volume of the music then gets set to the value the volume channel of the Echo Thing, not the actual volume that was playing via Sonos.
I created an issue for this - not sure if developers want to look into it, since I guess Sonos devices are not officially supported as per the documentation, but still it would be neat if it would work.
opened 04:34PM - 03 Feb 23 UTC
bug
I have been using the Amazon Echo Control binding to send Alexa voice notificati… ons to my Sonos speakers that are Alexa-enabled. Those can be added as things of type "echo" with the serial numbers from the Amazon Echo Control page. See also this [community díscussion](https://community.openhab.org/t/using-sonos-speakers-as-alexa-echo-via-amazon-echo-control-binding-sonos-arc-works-sonos-move-not/136882/14?u=the-ninth) on the topic.
By and large this works well, but there is an issue with the volume, with the volume channel and the linked items not getting updated when the volume is changed on the Sonos app or the device. The resulting problem is that after the Alexa voice notification is played, music is resumed with the volume stored in the volume channel, which is not the actual volume at which the music was played before.
## Expected Behavior
When the volume is changed via the Sonos app, on the Sonos device, or via any other means, the volume channel of the Echo binding should be updated.
## Current Behavior
When the volume is changed via the Sonos app, on the Sonos device, or via the Sonos binding, the volume channel of the Echo binding is not updated. The other direction works, when changing the volume on the Echo binding, the Sonos binding, app etc. do show the change, albeit there is a noticeable lag.
Here screenshots of my two Points. The first is representing the volume channel of the thing created for the device via the Sonos binding, which I just updated to 20. The second the volume channel of the thing created for the same Sonos device via the Echo binding, which stays at the value of 40.
## Steps to Reproduce (for Bugs)
1. Setup the Sonos device in the Sonos app
2. Add Alexa via the Sonos app
3. Create thing/items for the Sonos device via the Sonos binding
4. Create thing/items for the Sonos device via the Echo binding
5. Change the volume on the item created via the Sonos binding
6. Result: volume for the item created via the Echo binding is not updated
## Context
When sending an Alexa voice notification via the speak channel, the volume of the music previously is set wrongly to the value stored in the volume channel, which does not reflect the actual volume at which the music was played before.
## Your Environment
* openHAB 3.4.0, running in a docker container on a Synology DS420+
* For testing I used a Sonos One (2nd generation)
