ZWAVE-Binding: Popp 10 Year Smoke detector (009402) is recognized wrongly as Solar Powered Outdoor Siren (005107)

[pfkailuweit (Peter Fuß)]

I recently updated my Openhab installation after abandoning it for several months. Since then my Popp 10 Year Smoke detectors are recognized as Popps Solar Powered Outdoor Siren. There are several topics which actually seem to describe the opposite issue than mine:

https://community.openhab.org/t/popp-smoke-detector-and-siren/8316

It seems that my device returns Id 0004:0002 which is identical to that of the siren in the database. I would update the database myself, but I am not quite sure of how to proceed to avoid conflicts with the current devices in the database.

According to Habmin device info the Firmware version is 1.1
Here is the XML File generated by the binding to this ticket:

<node>
  <homeId>0xed228a36</homeId>
  <nodeId>7</nodeId>
  <version>4</version>
  <manufacturer>0x154</manufacturer>
  <deviceId>0x2</deviceId>
  <deviceType>0x4</deviceType>
  <listening>false</listening>
  <frequentlyListening>true</frequentlyListening>
  <routing>true</routing>
  <security>false</security>
  <beaming>true</beaming>
  <maxBaudRate>40000</maxBaudRate>
  <sleepDelay>1000</sleepDelay>
  <nodeInformationFrame>
    <commandClass>COMMAND_CLASS_ZWAVEPLUS_INFO</commandClass>
    <commandClass>COMMAND_CLASS_FIRMWARE_UPDATE_MD</commandClass>
    <commandClass>COMMAND_CLASS_POWERLEVEL</commandClass>
    <commandClass>COMMAND_CLASS_BATTERY</commandClass>
    <commandClass>COMMAND_CLASS_DEVICE_RESET_LOCALLY</commandClass>
    <commandClass>COMMAND_CLASS_SECURITY</commandClass>
    <commandClass>COMMAND_CLASS_VERSION</commandClass>
    <commandClass>COMMAND_CLASS_MANUFACTURER_SPECIFIC</commandClass>
    <commandClass>COMMAND_CLASS_MARK</commandClass>
    <commandClass>COMMAND_CLASS_BASIC</commandClass>
  </nodeInformationFrame>
  <associationGroups class="concurrent-hash-map"/>
  <endpoints class="concurrent-hash-map">
    <entry>
      <int>0</int>
      <endPoint>
        <deviceClass>
          <basicDeviceClass>BASIC_TYPE_ROUTING_SLAVE</basicDeviceClass>
          <genericDeviceClass>GENERIC_TYPE_SENSOR_NOTIFICATION</genericDeviceClass>
          <specificDeviceClass>SPECIFIC_TYPE_NOTIFICATION_SENSOR</specificDeviceClass>
        </deviceClass>
        <endpointId>0</endpointId>
        <secureCommandClasses/>
        <supportedCommandClasses class="concurrent-hash-map">
          <entry>
            <commandClass>COMMAND_CLASS_BATTERY</commandClass>
            <COMMAND__CLASS__BATTERY>
              <version>1</version>
              <instances>1</instances>
              <control>false</control>
              <versionSupported>1</versionSupported>
              <batteryLevel>100</batteryLevel>
              <batteryLow>false</batteryLow>
              <isGetSupported>true</isGetSupported>
            </COMMAND__CLASS__BATTERY>
          </entry>
          <entry>
            <commandClass>COMMAND_CLASS_SECURITY</commandClass>
            <COMMAND__CLASS__SECURITY>
              <version>1</version>
              <instances>1</instances>
              <control>false</control>
              <versionSupported>1</versionSupported>
            </COMMAND__CLASS__SECURITY>
          </entry>
          <entry>
            <commandClass>COMMAND_CLASS_ZWAVEPLUS_INFO</commandClass>
            <COMMAND__CLASS__ZWAVEPLUS__INFO>
              <version>1</version>
              <instances>1</instances>
              <control>false</control>
              <versionSupported>2</versionSupported>
              <zwPlusVersion>1</zwPlusVersion>
              <zwPlusRole>ROLE_TYPE_SLAVE_SLEEPING_LISTENING</zwPlusRole>
              <zwPlusNodeType>NODE_TYPE_ZWAVEPLUS_NODE</zwPlusNodeType>
              <isGetSupported>true</isGetSupported>
            </COMMAND__CLASS__ZWAVEPLUS__INFO>
          </entry>
          <entry>
            <commandClass>COMMAND_CLASS_NO_OPERATION</commandClass>
            <COMMAND__CLASS__NO__OPERATION>
              <version>1</version>
              <instances>1</instances>
              <control>false</control>
              <versionSupported>1</versionSupported>
            </COMMAND__CLASS__NO__OPERATION>
          </entry>
          <entry>
            <commandClass>COMMAND_CLASS_VERSION</commandClass>
            <COMMAND__CLASS__VERSION>
              <version>2</version>
              <instances>1</instances>
              <control>false</control>
              <versionSupported>2</versionSupported>
              <libraryType>LIB_SLAVE_ENHANCED</libraryType>
              <protocolVersion>4.5</protocolVersion>
              <applicationVersion>1.1</applicationVersion>
              <hardwareVersion>1</hardwareVersion>
            </COMMAND__CLASS__VERSION>
          </entry>
          <entry>
            <commandClass>COMMAND_CLASS_BASIC</commandClass>
            <COMMAND__CLASS__BASIC>
              <version>1</version>
              <instances>1</instances>
              <control>false</control>
              <versionSupported>1</versionSupported>
              <isGetSupported>true</isGetSupported>
            </COMMAND__CLASS__BASIC>
          </entry>
          <entry>
            <commandClass>COMMAND_CLASS_DEVICE_RESET_LOCALLY</commandClass>
            <COMMAND__CLASS__DEVICE__RESET__LOCALLY>
              <version>1</version>
              <instances>1</instances>
              <control>false</control>
              <versionSupported>1</versionSupported>
            </COMMAND__CLASS__DEVICE__RESET__LOCALLY>
          </entry>
          <entry>
            <commandClass>COMMAND_CLASS_POWERLEVEL</commandClass>
            <COMMAND__CLASS__POWERLEVEL>
              <version>1</version>
              <instances>1</instances>
              <control>false</control>
              <versionSupported>1</versionSupported>
              <powerLevel>0</powerLevel>
              <powerTimeout>0</powerTimeout>
            </COMMAND__CLASS__POWERLEVEL>
          </entry>
          <entry>
            <commandClass>COMMAND_CLASS_FIRMWARE_UPDATE_MD</commandClass>
            <COMMAND__CLASS__FIRMWARE__UPDATE__MD>
              <version>1</version>
              <instances>1</instances>
              <control>false</control>
              <versionSupported>3</versionSupported>
            </COMMAND__CLASS__FIRMWARE__UPDATE__MD>
          </entry>
          <entry>
            <commandClass>COMMAND_CLASS_MANUFACTURER_SPECIFIC</commandClass>
            <COMMAND__CLASS__MANUFACTURER__SPECIFIC>
              <version>1</version>
              <instances>1</instances>
              <control>false</control>
              <versionSupported>2</versionSupported>
              <initSerialNumber>false</initSerialNumber>
              <deviceManufacturer>340</deviceManufacturer>
              <deviceType>4</deviceType>
              <deviceId>2</deviceId>
            </COMMAND__CLASS__MANUFACTURER__SPECIFIC>
          </entry>
        </supportedCommandClasses>
      </endPoint>
    </entry>
  </endpoints>
  <nodeNeighbors>
    <int>1</int>
    <int>6</int>
    <int>8</int>
  </nodeNeighbors>
  <lastReceived>2019-01-24 19:56:58.400 UTC</lastReceived>
</node>

I would appreciate if anyone has an idea to resolve this issue.

[sihui]

@pfkailuweit

I would appreciate if anyone has an idea to resolve this issue.

The database is correct, it seems to be a problem with the device. Please read this thread (and all posts down to the bottom), you may need to update the firmware of that device:

POPP 10 year Smoke Detector has possibly the wrong id

There’s no nice way to do this I think. All I can currently suggest is to include the device into the network, let it create the XML, and then edit the XML to set it to 0004:0004. This should work so long as the XML doesn’t get deleted (which can happen if there are changes to the binding that impact the format). The other option (maybe!) is to send the incorrect ones back to Popp and ask them to replace them with ones that are correctly defined, as per their own statement above ;).

BUT: first step will be to upgrade to the latest 2.5 zwave snapshot binding version to see it the problem persists.

[pfkailuweit (Peter Fuß)]

Hi,

thank you for your answer. Indeed I haven’t noticed this post so far. I will try to walk all these steps and see ift it helps…