Icons are shown in wrong state

Apps & Services Android App
1

In the BasicUI the icons are changing to the correct state, but on Android I see the wrong icons.

I have 3 files light.svg, light-on.svg and light-off.svg! The light.svg icon is the -off icon!
But I see always the light-on.svg icon.

Another example is the motion icon.
Also 3 icons motion.svg, motion-on.svg and motion-off.svg!
And I see always the motion-on.svg icon.

If I remove my custom made icons for the light bulp I see the correct states again.

Did I miss something or is this still a known problem?
The problem is in local and remote connection.

I have only found this very old thread:

2

Are you sure that your item state is ON or OFF? Look in events.log

4

Yes I see it in the Visual Studio Code and it is working in the BasicUI.
I tap on my button “OFF” and the item gets the state “OFF” and I see the correct icon in the BasicUI in the Web Browser on my PC.

Now I check the Android app and I see the wrong icon.

5

Do you have the data saver mode enabled?

6

No is off. Never had that on.

The strange thing is that if I check the log inside the app I see that the app is requesting the correct state icon.
If I type exact the same http url as in the log on my browser I see the correct icon, but the app shows a wrong one.

Already did an openHab restart, App cache clear, App data clear but without success.

7

Can you post the “Device information” part of the log? It’s at the beginning of the log.

8

Device information
Model: Pixel 4
Manufacturer: Google
Brand: google
Device: flame
Product: flame
OS: 11
Display: 1080x2236, 2.75 density

9

Is there a line called “Data usage policy” after “Display”? Which version are you using?

Edit: The data usage policy isn’t shown in the latest stable verion.

10

No after Display there are the line with -
Afterwards I see “beginning of main”.

11

I see now this in the logs:
https://openhab-local-address:8443/icon/motion2?format=SVG&anyFormat=true&state=OFF

The strange thing is that the “openhab-local-address” is not replaced with the correct IP.
This was before my clear data not the case.

Should I send you the complete log?

12

I installed the BETA version and now I see the data usage policy.
Here again the entries:
Device information
Model: Pixel 4
Manufacturer: Google
Brand: google
Device: flame
Product: flame
OS: 11
Display: 1080x2236, 2.75 density
Data usage policy: DataUsagePolicy(canDoLargeTransfers=true, loadIconsWithState=true, autoPlayVideos=true, canDoRefreshes=true), data saver: 1, battery saver: false

13

The real address is only redacted in the log.

Which server version do you use?

14

You mean openHab version?
This is 2.5.10.

15

Small Update.
If I use .png icons the problem seems solved.

So there is something wrong if I use the .svg icons.

16

The app has the following order for icons. The first one found is used:

  1. Custom SVG
  2. Custom PNG
  3. Built-in SVG
  4. Built-in PNG

However this should be the same than in Basic UI.

17

Ok so do you need any additional Infos?
As mentioned with png it is working and with svg I have this strange behavior.

18

This sounds like a server side bug. Can you open an issue at https://github.com/openhab/openhab-core/?

19

Sure will do. Thanks.

20

As it works well in BasicUI I really don’t think about a core problem.
Maybe a cache problem in Android app?
You could also try to use a different icon name than the one from the official iconset. Try with mylight.

21

You are right. The BasicUI in the browser is working. So it should not be a core problem.
But I have already cleared the cache and the data of the android app.

Also I have tried a different icon name. No success.

As mentioned above I use now png files and all is working fine.